- Research article
- Open Access
Incudomalleal joint formation: the roles of apoptosis, migration and downregulation
© Amin et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2007
- Received: 08 May 2007
- Accepted: 05 December 2007
- Published: 05 December 2007
The middle ear of mammals is composed of three endochondrial ossicles, the stapes, incus and malleus. Joints link the malleus to the incus and the incus to the stapes. In the mouse the first arch derived malleus and incus are formed from a single Sox9 and Type II collagen expressing condensation that later subdivides to give rise to two separate ossicles. In contrast the stapes forms from a separate condensation derived from the second branchial arch. Fusion of the malleus and incus is observed in a number of human syndromes and results in conductive hearing loss. Understanding how this joint forms during normal development is thus an important step in furthering our understanding of such defects.
We show that the developing incudomalleal joint is characterised by a lack of proliferation and discrete areas of apoptosis. Apoptosis has been suggested to aid in the removal of pre-cartilaginous cells from the joint region, allowing for the physical separation of the cartilaginous elements, however, we show that joint initiation is unaffected by blocking apoptosis. There is also no evidence of cell migration out of the presumptive joint region, as observed by labelling of joint and ossicle cells in culture. Using Type II collagen lacZ reporter mice, however, it is evident that cells in the presumptive joint region remain in place and downregulate cartilage markers.
The malleus and incus first appear as a single united condensation expressing early cartilage markers. The incudomalleal joint region forms by cells in the presumptive joint region switching off cartilage markers and turning on joint markers. Failure in this process may result in fusion of this joint, as observed in human syndromes such as Branchio-Oto-Renal Syndrome or Treacher Collins Syndrome.
- Joint Region
- Joint Formation
- Treacher Collins Syndrome
- General Caspase Inhibitor
- Cartilage Marker
In the mouse the malleus and incus of the middle ear initially develop as a single element that expresses cartilage markers such as Type II collagen and Sox9. This united structure then subdivides to form the two ossicles divided by the incudomalleal joint [1, 2]. This early joint region is free of Type II collagen or Sox9 expressing cells and expresses joint markers such as Gdf5 . Sox9 has been shown to upregulate Type II collagen expression, and overexpression of Sox9 leads to ectopic cartilage formation [3, 4]. Loss of Sox9 and Type II collagen, therefore, is thought to play an important role in formation of the joint.
The formation of three ossicles in the middle ear (malleus, incus and stapes) is a characteristic of mammals. During the course of evolution the primary jaw articulation of non-mammalian vertebrates was replaced by a second articulation between two membranous bones, the squamosal and dentary . Studies involving comparative anatomy, embryology and paleontology have suggested that the primary jaw articulation, along with the hyomandibular (columella in chick and reptiles) were incorporated into the middle ear to form a three ossicle chain. Using this criteria, the malleus is homologous to the articular part of Meckel's cartilage, the incus is homologous to the quadrate/palatoquadrate, and the stapes is homologous to the hypomandibular [5, 6]. The incudomalleal joint is therefore homologous to the primary jaw joint. Homology has been confirmed by investigating expression of genes such as Bapx1 (Nkx3.2), which is specifically expressed in the primary jaw joint of Xenopus, zebrafish and chick and in the incudomalleal joint in mammals [7–10]. Like the incudomalleal joint, the primary jaw joint divides two initially continuous elements expressing Type II collagen, the quadrate and articular part of Meckel's cartilage . These two cartilages then separate to form the articulation point for the upper and lower jaws.
In a variety of human syndromes, such as Treacher Collins and Branchio-Oto-Renal (BOR) syndrome, the malleus and incus are often fused resulting in conductive hearing loss [11–14]. The development of this joint is therefore essential to ensure correct hearing. It is thus of interest to examine what happens to these presumptive joint cells that are initially fated to become cartilage.
In a variety of limb joints, apoptosis has been observed within the interzone at the centre of the developing joint . Such programmed cell death was postulated to account for the loss of the cartilage lineage cells within the forming joint, leading to the separation of skeletal elements [16–20]. Given this data from the limb, we wished to investigate the role of apoptosis in early joint formation in the middle ear.
Apoptosis can be mediated by distinct pathways initiating from within (intrinsic) or outside (extrinsic) the cell. Both pathways involve signalling via a family of cysteine proteases named caspases . Caspase machinery becomes activated in a cascade manner starting with apical caspases, such as Caspase 8 and Caspase 9, leading to cleavage of effector caspases, such as Caspase 3. Caspase 8 mutants die at E11.5 due to cardiovascular abnormalities , but Caspase 9 and Caspase 3 mutant mice survive up to and past birth depending on the strain [23–26]. These mutants display a strikingly similar phenotype, characterised by a prominent brain malformation caused by defective apoptosis in the proliferative neuroepithelium [25, 26]. Caspase 9 is activated within a complex known as the apoptosome, where the pro-caspase 9 interacts with Cytochrome c and Apaf-1 . Cytochrome c deficient mice die at E8.5 , however the majority of Apaf-1 mutant mice survive up to E18.5. These mice exhibit defects in the brain, inner ear and digits [29–31]. The middle ear can therefore be analysed in Apaf-1, Caspase 3, and Caspase 9 mutant mice.
To knock down activation of all caspases, an in vitro approach must be applied and pharmacological inhibitors binding to the active site of activated caspases are generally used . We have therefore devised a method for culturing the middle ear in the presence or absence of caspase activity. By these two methods the role of apoptosis in formation of the incudomalleal joint can be analysed.
In the digits, developing cartilage recruits neighbouring cells into the cartilage creating high cell density in these regions . It was therefore possible that the Sox9/Type II collagen expressing cells in the presumptive joint might migrate out of the forming joint into the body of the malleus or incus. To test this we labelled cells in the forming incudomalleal joint region and developing malleus with the lipophilic dyes DiO and DiI, and observed the movements of labelled cells as the joint formed in culture.
Alternatively, the Sox9/Type II collagen positive cells might remain in position and downregulate expression of these genes. To investigate this possibility we have utilised Type II collagen lacZ reporter mice, where the stable lacZ protein marks cells that express Type II collagen and also those that have recently switched off Type II collagen.
By these methods we hope to determine what processes are involved in early joint development in the middle ear.
Wild type and Type II collagen LacZ reporter mouse embryos were dissected out at embryonic day (E) 13.5 to 18.5.
Caspase 3/C57BI/6J mutant mice were provided by Dr. S. Lakhani (Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, USA).
Caspase 9/C57BI/6J mutant mice were provide by Prof. K.A. Roth (Department of Neuropathology, University of Alabama, USA).
Apaf-1 mutant mice were generated as described in .
All research on animals follows internationally recognized guidelines. Use of genetically modified organisms was approved by the local Genetic Modification Safety Committee (GMSC).
Middle ear explant culture system
Middle ear regions were dissected from the lateral parts of mouse embryonic heads, and placed on Millipore filters supported on metal grids over medium using a modified Trowell method . Culture medium consisted of DMEM (Sigma) supplemented with glutamine, pen/strep and 10% fetal calf serum. Fresh medium was delivered every 24 h and cultures were kept at 37°C, 5% CO2 for up to 4 days.
The pharmaceutical inhibitor of general caspase Z-VAD-FMK (R&D Systems) was dissolved in ACS DMSO (Sigma Aldrich) and added to the fresh culture medium at a final concentration of 200 μM. Control medium was supplemented by 1%DMSO corresponding to the amount of DMSO in the inhibitor solution, as has been used in previous publications . Culture medium was changed every day for 3 days.
Biotinylated pan caspase inhibitor (R&D Systems) was exploited to check the distribution of the inhibitor throughout the explant. The pan caspase inhibitor was applied in the same way as the general one and its distribution was traced in histological sections after addition of streptavidin-AP (BD Biosciences) and NBT/BCIP colour reaction, showing successful spread of the inhibitor (data not shown).
The effect of the inhibitor on apoptosis was tested in developing limbs where the interdigital tissue is known to disappear by caspase dependent apoptosis . Front limbs from E12.5 mouse embryos were cultured simultaneously and in the same way as the middle ear cultures for 24–72 hours. Formation of digits and interdigital space was documented microscopically.
Embryos were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde and dehydrated to 100% ethanol. Paraffin wax sections were cut at 8 μm and split over 5 to 6 slides. Serial sections were stained with hematoxylin/eosin to visualize the early tissue morphology or with Sirrus red and Alcian blue to view the developing bones and cartilage.
Type II collagen LacZ reporter mice were fixed and stained with β galactosidase in wholemount as described in .
PCNA (proliferating cell nuclear antigen)
A polyclonal PCNA antibody (Santa Cruz) was applied for 1 hour (room temperature) after pretreatment in 0.01 M citric buffer (microwave irradiation for 10 mins). Application of the secondary antibody (labeled with horse radish peroxidase – HRP) for 30 mins was followed by a colour reaction using 3',3 '-diaminobensidine (DAB) as the substrate.
Anti-phosphohistone H3 immunohistochemistry
Embryos were fixed in 5% acetic acid in ethanol overnight at 4°C, dehydrated through a graded series of ethanol, embedded in paraffin wax and sectioned. Sections were processed for antibody staining using rabbit anti-phosphorylated histone 3 (1:200 dilution, Upstate Biotechnology, Lake Placid, NY) as described previously . The antibody targets were visualized with Alexa-fluor 568-goat-anti-rabbit-IgG (1:500 dilution, Molecular probes, Leiden, the Netherlands). Slides were mounted in Slowfade Gold antifade reagent with DAPI (Molecular Probes) according to manufacturers instructions and visualized by fluorescence microscopy (Carl Zeiss, New York).
An ApopTag Peroxidase In Situ Apoptosis Detection Kit was used to detect apoptotic DNA breaks in individual cells (Chemicon). For the Colour reaction a DAB Substrate Kit was used, with Nickel staining to give a black colour (Vector Labs). Eosin was used for counterstaining of the sections.
Nuclear condensations and formation of apoptotic bodies were evaluated additionally to the TUNEL test .
DiI (1,1' dioctadecyl-3, 3,3',3'-tetramethyl-indocarbocyanine perchlorate) and DiO (3,3'-dioctadecyloxacarbocyanine perchlorate) were used as cell lineage labels. A stock solution of DiI (Cell tracker- Molecular probes) (0.5%) was made in 100% ethanol and diluted 1:9 with 0.3 M sucrose on the day of use. For the DiO labelling, a ready-made Vybrant DiO cell-labelling solution was used (Invitrogen). The Dil solution was injected into the developing malleus of dissected lower jaws using a mouth pipette connected to a pulled glass needle. By a similar method DiO was injected into the presumptive joint region between the malleus and incus. The cultures were then moved to explant culture dishes and photographed under light and dark field. Cultures were left to develop for 48 hours and photographed at 24 hour intervals.
Type II collagen Immunohistochemistry
Type II collagen immunohistochemistry was performed using 11–116B3 antibody (Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank) on paraffin wax sections. To enhance the signal, slides were microwaved in 0.01 M citrate buffer , and treated with Chondroitinase ABC at 0.25 U per ml and Hyaluronidase at 1.45 U per ml at 37°C for 45 minutes (Sigma). The collagen antibody was used at a dilution of 1:100.
Radioactive in situhybridisation
Radioactive in situs were performed using 35S as described . Gdf5 probe was linearised with HindIII and transcribed with T7.
Proliferation in the incudomalleal joint
At E13.5 the malleus and incus are still continuous . At this early stage using PCNA, proliferation was observed in the malleus and incus but the forming joint region was negative, reflecting the situation observed at later stages (Fig. 1G,H). Using the H3 antibody at this stage, the incus showed positive proliferating cells but the presumptive joint region appeared negative (Fig. 1I). The malleus also appeared negative, using the antibody to H3, perhaps indicating a time delay between proliferation of the two ossicles.
Apoptosis in the incudomalleal joint
To investigate the functional significance of these areas of apoptosis for middle ear development, we investigated middle ear development in mice where different components of the apoptotic machinery had been knocked out, and used an explant culture system to block the action of all caspases in this region.
Pro-apoptotic molecules Apaf-1, Caspase 3 and 9are not involved in the initiation of the incudomalleal joint
Caspase inhibition in middle ear explant culture
Middle ears were dissected out at E12.5, several days prior to any morphological sign of a joint. These were then cultured for 3 days until a clear joint could be observed between the malleus and incus in control cultures. In cultures treated with the general caspase inhibitor a normal joint was observed, free from cartilaginous cells (Fig. 5C) (N = 4).
Downregulation of cartilage markers
Cells in the joint region at E14.5 expressed LacZ (blue), while the surrounding ossicles expressed both LacZ (blue) and the Type II collagen protein (brown) (Fig. 7D,E). Thus the Type II collagen expressing cells have remained in the same position and downregulated expression of chondrogenic genes.
Apoptosis has been described as a sculptor of development in many mammalian structures and is observed in developing limb joints [16–20]. Thus it seems a good candidate process for removal of Sox9/Type II collagen expressing cells to create a joint, and thereby separate the malleus and incus. Apoptotic cells were observed early on between the malleus and incus, however, Apaf-1, Caspase 3 and Caspase 9 mutant mice exhibited normal division of the malleus and incus at E15.5. No middle ear defect was also observed in Apaf-1 mutants at E17.5. This is despite the loss of TUNEL positive cells in the mutant. This result was confirmed in explant culture by using caspase inhibitors. Thus formation of the middle ear joint appears independent of apoptosis. It may be, however, that loss of apoptosis is compensated for by cell death through other processes, such as necrosis or caspase independent programmed cell death, such as paraptosis . Paraptosis, like apoptosis, is programmed cell death but is independent of the normal apoptotic machinery . In the limbs of Apaf-1 mutants interdigital cell death is initially inhibited but after a delay of a few days, cell death in these regions is observed, resulting in separation of the digits. This interdigital cell death occurs despite no evidence of TUNEL positive cells or overall cell condensation . Thus in the absence of apoptosis, as indicated by TUNEL staining, cells may still be able to die.
Migration is another candidate process that could explain the disappearance of cartilaginous presumptive joint cells. DiI and DiO double labelling was used to trace the movement of cells in the presumptive joint region over 2 days. Results show that although the joint region changes shape, the labelled cells in the joint region did not move towards the DiI labelled cells and were not incorporated into the malleus. This is perhaps unsurprising as chondrogenic precursors have been shown to have a low migration capacity when compared to many other cells types, such as myogenic precursors .
By comparing the expression of Type II collagen protein and a LacZ reporter driven by the same promoter, we have shown that the initially chondrogenic cells remain in the incudomalleal joint region and downregulate expression of chondrogenic markers. In this way Type II collagen is turned off and joint markers, such as Gdf5, are turned on in the same cells. The signal to trigger this event is as yet unknown. It is thus unclear how cells only in the presumptive joint region turn off Type II collagen, while those on either side carry on with a cartilage differentiation pathway. The homeobox gene Emx2 may play a role in demarcating the future joint as it is expressed in the incus and presumptive joint but excluded from the malleus, prior to the separation of these two ossicles . In keeping with this role, mutations in Emx2 lead to loss of both the incus and joint . Joint markers, such as Bapx1 and Gdf5, have been shown to turn on before loss of Sox9 and Type II collagen . It is possible, therefore, that these joint markers act by directly repressing cartilage development. Overexpression of Gdf5, however, is unable to induce formation of an ectopic joint, thus although this gene has an important role in joint formation it is not sufficient to repress cartilage development [53, 54]. In contrast, overexpression of Wnt signalling is sufficient to induce an ectopic joint . The role of Wnt signalling in formation of the incudomalleal joint and its relationship to the loss of cartilage markers is thus an interesting avenue to pursue. What leads to the induction of joint markers at the future incudo-malleal joint is also unclear. In the chick and zebrafish, Bapx1 acts upstream of Gdf5 in development of the primary jaw joint, with the expression of Bapx1 being controlled by a combination of inhibitory and inducing signals from Fgfs, Bmps and Endothelin [8, 9]. Whether a similar combination of signals leads to the restriction of joint markers in the mammalian middle ear is therefore another important area for future study. Such comparative work will allow for further understanding of how cranial joints are initiated and positioned and will focus in on the genetic pathways that may have played a role in changing the pattern of joints during evolution.
The incudomalleal joint in the mammalian middle ear separates the initially united incus and malleus. The forming joint is characterised by a lack of proliferation, compared to the ossicles on either side, and contains a number of cells undergoing cell death (apoptosis). In the absence of apoptosis, however, no defect in joint formation is observed. Cells in the joint region do not move away from this position but instead downregulate cartilage markers and take on a joint fate, expressing genes such as Gdf5. Fusions of the middle ear, as seen in patients with BOR Syndrome or Treacher Collins Syndrome, may therefore occur if presumptive joint cells fail to downregulate expression of chondrogenic genes. Many of the genes underlying such syndromes have been discovered, and so the next challenge is to investigate such possibilities using mouse models.
Apoptosis research in Brno is supported by the Grant Agency of the Czech Academy of Sciences (B500450503). Susan Amin, Carol Simpson and Abigail Tucker are funded by the MRC (Grant GO501037). Thanks to Dr S. Lakhani and Prof. K. A. Roth who kindly sent mutant embryos, and to Benoit de Crombrugghe for the Type II Collagen LacZ reporter mice. The Gdf5 probe was a gift from Frank Luyton. The Type II collagen antibody, developed by T. F. Linsenmayer, was obtained from the Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank developed under the auspices of the NICHD and maintained by the University of Iowa, Department of Biological Sciences, Iowa City, IA 52242. PCNA work was created during a Short Term Scientific Mission (STSM) funded by COST action B23.
- Amin S, Tucker AS: Joint formation in the middle ear: lessons from the mouse and guinea pig. Dev Dyn. 2006, 235: 1326-33. 10.1002/dvdy.20666.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Miyake T, Cameron AM, Hall BK: Stage-specific onset of condensation and matrix deposition for Meckel's and other first arch cartilages in inbred C57BL/6 mice. J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol. 1996, 16: 32-47.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Bell DM, Leung KK, Wheatley SC, Hg LJ, Zhou S, Ling KW, Sham MH, Koopman P, Tam PP, Cheah KS: Sox9 directly regulates the type-II collagen gene. Nat Genet. 1997, 16: 174-178. 10.1038/ng0697-174.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Healy C, Uwanogho D, Sharpe PT: Regulation and role of Sox9 in cartilage formation. Dev Dyn. 1999, 215: 69-78. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0177(199905)215:1<69::AID-DVDY8>3.0.CO;2-N.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fleischer G: Evolutionary principles of the mammalian middle ear. Adv Anat Embryol Cell Biol. 1978, 55 (5): 3-70.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Allin EF, Hopson JA: Evolution of the auditory system in Synapsida ('mammal like reptiles" and primitive mammals) as seen in the fossil record. The evolutionary biology of hearing. Edited by: Webster DB, Fay RR, Popper AN. 1992, New York: Springer-Verlag, 587-614.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Newman CS, Grow MW, Cleaver O, Chai F, Krieg P: Xbap, a vertebrate gene related to bagpipe is expressed in developing craniofacial structures and in anterior gut muscle. Dev Biol. 1997, 181: 223-233. 10.1006/dbio.1996.8416.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Miller CT, Yelon D, Stainier DYR, Kimmel CB: Two endothelin 1 effectors, hand2 and bapx1, pattern ventral pharyngeal cartilage and the jaw joint. Development. 2003, 130: 1353-1365. 10.1242/dev.00339.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wilson J, Tucker AS: Fgf and Bmp signals repress the expression of Bapx1 in the mandibular mesenchyme and control the position of the developing jaw joint. Dev Biol. 2004, 266: 138-150. 10.1016/j.ydbio.2003.10.012.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tucker AS, Watson RP, Lettice LA, Yamada G, Hill RE: Bapx1 regulates patterning in the middle ear: altered regulatory role in the transition from the proximal jaw during vertebrate evolution. Development. 2004, 131: 1235-45. 10.1242/dev.01017.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Melnick M, Bixler D, Nance WE, Silk K, Yune H: Familial branchio-oto-renal dysplasia: a new addition to the branchial arch syndromes. Clin Genet. 1976, 9: 25-34.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fraser FC, Sproule JR, Halal F: Frequency of the branchio-oto-renal (BOR) syndrome in children with profound hearing loss. Am J Med Genet. 1980, 7: 341-9. 10.1002/ajmg.1320070316.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Phelps PD, Poswillo D, Lloyd GA: The ear deformities in mandibulofacial dysostosis (Treacher Collins syndrome). Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci. 1981, 6: 15-28. 10.1111/j.1365-2273.1981.tb01782.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jahrsdoerfer RA, Aguilar EA, Yeakley JW, Cole RR: Treacher Collins syndrome: an otologic challenge. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1989, 98: 807-12.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fernandez-Teran MA, Hinchliffe JR, Ros MA: Birth and Death of cells in limb development: A mapping study. Dev Dyn. 2006, 235: 2521-2537. 10.1002/dvdy.20916.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mitrovic D: Development of the diarthrodial joints in the rat embryo. Am J Anat. 1978, 151: 475-85. 10.1002/aja.1001510403.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mitrovic DR: Development of the metatarsophalangeal joint of the chick embryo: morphological, ultrastructural and histochemical studies. Am J Anat. 1977, 150: 333-47. 10.1002/aja.1001500207.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nalin AM, Greenlee TK, Sandell LJ: Collagen gene expression during development of avian synovial joints: transient expression of types II and XI collagen genes in the joint capsule. Dev Dyn. 1995, 203: 352-62.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kimura S, Shiota K: Sequential changes of programmed cell death in developing fetal mouse limbs and its possible roles in limb morphogenesis. J Morphol. 1996, 229: 337-46. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-4687(199609)229:3<337::AID-JMOR8>3.0.CO;2-V.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mori C, Nakamura N, Kimura S, Irie H, Takigawa T, Shiota K: Programmed cell death in the interdigital tissue of the fetal mouse limb is apoptosis with DNA fragmentation. Anat Rec. 1995, 242: 103-10. 10.1002/ar.1092420114.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Earnshaw WC, Martins LM, Kaufmann SH: Mammalian caspases: structure, activation, substrates, and functions during apoptosis. Annu Rev Biochem. 1999, 68: 383-424. 10.1146/annurev.biochem.68.1.383.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Varfolomeev EE, Schuchmann M, Luria V, Chiannilkulchai N, Beckmann JS, Mett IL, Rebrikov D, Brodianski VM, Kemper OC, Kollet O, Lapidot T, Soffer D, Sobe T, Abraham KB, Goncharov T, Holtmann H, Lonai P, Wallach D: Targeted disruption of the mouse Caspase 8 gene ablates cell death induction by the TNF receptors, Fas/Apo1, and DR3 and is lethal prenatally. Immunity. 1998, 9: 267-76. 10.1016/S1074-7613(00)80609-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Takahashi K, Kamiya K, Urase K, Suga M, Takizawa T, Mori H, Yoshikawa Y, Ichimura K, Kuida K, Momoi T: Caspase-3-deficiency induces hyperplasia of supporting cells and degeneration of sensory cells resulting in hearing loss. Brain Res. 2001, 894: 359-67. 10.1016/S0006-8993(01)02123-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zheng T: Caspase 3 controls both cytoplasmic and nuclear events associated with fas mediated apoptosis in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1998, 95: 13618-23. 10.1073/pnas.95.23.13618.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kuida K, Haydar TF, Kuan CY, Gu Y, Taya C, Karasuyama H, Rakic P, Flavell RA: Reduced apoptosis and cytochrome c-mediated caspase activation in mice lacking caspase 9. Cell. 1998, 94: 325-337. 10.1016/S0092-8674(00)81476-2.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Leonard JR, Klocke BJ, D'Sa C, Flavell RA, Roth KA: Strain dependent neurodevelopmental abnormalities in caspase 3 deficient mice. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 2002, 61 (8): 673-677.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ferraro E, Corvaro M, Cecconi F: Physiological and pathological roles of Apaf-1 and apoptosome. J Cell Mol Med. 2003, 7: 21-34. 10.1111/j.1582-4934.2003.tb00199.x.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Li K, Shelton JM, Richardson JA, Spencer E, Chen ZJ, Wang X, Williams RS: Cytochrome c deficiency causes embryonic lethality and attenuates stress-induced apoptosis. Cell. 2002, 101: 389-399. 10.1016/S0092-8674(00)80849-1.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cecconi F, Alvarez-Bolado G, Meyer BI, Roth KA, Gruss P: Apaf1 (CED-4 homolog) regulates programmed cell death in mammalian development. Cell. 1998, 94: 727-37. 10.1016/S0092-8674(00)81732-8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cecconi F, Roth KA, Dolgov O, Munarriz E, Anokhin K, Gruss P, Salminen M: Apaf1-dependent programmed cell death is required for inner ear morphogenesis and growth. Development. 2004, 131: 2125-35. 10.1242/dev.01082.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yoshida H, Kong YY, Yoshida R, Elia AJ, Hakem A, Hakem R, Penninger JM, Mak TW: Apaf1 is required for mitochondrial pathways of apoptosis and brain development. Cell. 1998, 94: 739-50. 10.1016/S0092-8674(00)81733-X.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Linton SD: Caspase inhibitors: a pharmaceutical industry perspective. Curr Top Med Chem. 2005, 5: 1697-717. 10.2174/156802605775009720.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Omi M, Sato-Maeda M, Ide H: Role of chondrogenic tissue in programmed cell death and BMP expression in chick limb buds. Int J Dev Biol. 2000, 44: 381-8.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Trowell OA: The culture of mature organs in a synthetic medium. Exp Cell Res. 1959, 16: 118-47. 10.1016/0014-4827(59)90201-0.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Coin R, Kieffer S, Lesot H, Vonesch JL, Ruch JV: Inhibition of apoptosis in the primary enamel knot does not affect specific tooth crown morphogenesis in the mouse. Int J Dev Biol. 2000, 44: 389-96.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zuzarte-Luis V, Berciano MT, Lafarga M, Hurle JM: Caspase redundancy and release of mitochondrial apoptotic factors characterize interdigital apoptosis. Apoptosis. 2006, 11: 701-15. 10.1007/s10495-006-5481-8.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zhou G, Garofalo S, Mukhopadhyay K, Lefebvre V, Smith CN, Eberspaecher H, de Crombrugghe B: A 182 bp fragment of the mouse pro alpha 1(II) collagen gene is sufficient to direct chondrocyte expression in transgenic mice. J Cell Sci. 1995, 108: 3677-84.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Dhomen NS, Balaggan KS, Pearson RA, Bainbridge JW, Levine EM, Ali RR, Sowden JC: Absence of Chx10 causes neural progenitors to persist in the adult retina. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Sci. 2006, 47: 386-396. 10.1167/iovs.05-0428.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Setkova J, Matalova E, Sharpe PT, Misek I, Tucker AS: Primary enamel knot cell death in apaf1 and caspase 9 deficient mice. Arch Oral Biol. 2007, 52: 15-19. 10.1016/j.archoralbio.2006.07.006.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Shi SR, Key ME, Kalra KL: Antigen retrieval in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues: an enhancement method for immunohistochemical staining based on microwave oven heating of tissue sections. J Histochem Cytochem. 1991, 39 (6): 741-748.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tucker AS, Yamada G, Grigoriou M, Pachnis V, Sharpe PT: Fgf8 determines rostral-caudal polarity in the first branchial arch. Development. 1999, 126: 51-61.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Edwards JC, Wilkinson LS, Jones HM, Soothill P, Henderson KJ, Worrall JG, Pitsillides AA: The formation of human synovial joint cavities: a possible role for hyaluronan and CD44 in altered interzone cohesion. J Anat. 1994, 185: 355-67.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Archer CW, Morrison H, Pitsillides AA: Cellular aspects of the development of diarthrodial joints and articular cartilage. J Anat. 1994, 184: 447-56.PubMed CentralPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kavanagh E, Abiri M, Bland YS, Ashhurst DE: Division and death of cells in developing synovial joints and long bones. Cell Biol Int. 2002, 26: 679-88. 10.1006/cbir.2002.0918.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Muskhelishvili L, Latendrese JR, Kodell RL, Henderson EB: Evaluation of cell proliferation in rat tissues with BrDU, PCNA, Ki-67 (MIB-5) Immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridisation for HIstone mRNA. J Histochem Cytochem. 2003, 51: 1681-1688.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nishizaki K, Anniko M, Orita Y, Masuda Y, Yoshino T, Kanda S, Sasaki J: Programmed cell death in the development of the mouse external auditory canal. Anat Rec. 1998, 252: 378-82. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0185(199811)252:3<378::AID-AR5>3.0.CO;2-#.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mallo M: Assembling a funcional typanic memebrane: signals from the external acoustic meatus coordinate development of the malleal manubrium. Development. 2000, 127: 4127-4136.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Broker LE, Kruyt FA, Giaccone G: Cell death independent of caspases: a review. Clin Cancer Res. 2005, 11: 3155-3162. 10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-04-2223.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sperandio S, de Belle I, Bredesen DE: An alternative, nonapoptotic form of programmed cell death. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2000, 97: 14276-12381. 10.1073/pnas.97.26.14376.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chautan M, Chazal G, Cecconi F, Gruss P, Golstein P: Interdigital cell death can occur through a necrotic and caspase-independent pathway. Current Biol. 1999, 9: 967-970. 10.1016/S0960-9822(99)80425-4.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kosher RA, Rodgers BJ: Separation of the myogenic and chondrogenic progenitor cells of undifferentiated limb mesenchyme. Dev Biol. 1987, 121: 376-88. 10.1016/0012-1606(87)90174-6.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rhodes CR, Parkinson N, Tsai H, Brooker D, Mansell S, Spurr N, Hunter AJ, Steel KP, Brown SD: The homeobox gene Emx2 underlies middle ear and inner ear defects in the deaf mouse mutant pardon. J Neurocytol. 2003, 32: 1143-54. 10.1023/B:NEUR.0000021908.98337.91.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Francis-West P, Richardson MK, Bell E, Chen P, Luyten F, Adelfattah A, Barlow AJ, Brickell PM, Wolpert L, Archer CW: The effect of overexpression of BMPs and GDF-5 on the development of chick limb skeletal elements. Ann NY Acad Sci. 1996, 785: 254-255.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tsumaki N, Nakase T, Miyaji T, Kakiuchi M, Kimura T, Ochi T, Yoshikawa H: Bone morphogenetic protein signals are required for cartilage formation and differently regulate joint development during skeletogenesis. J Bone Miner Res. 2002, 17: 898-906. 10.1359/jbmr.2002.17.5.898.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guo X, Day TF, Jiang X, Garrett-Beal L, Topol L, Yang Y: Wnt/B-catenin signalling is sufficient and necessary for synovial joint formation. Genes and Development. 2004, 18: 2404-2417. 10.1101/gad.1230704.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.