- Research article
- Open Access
Ptf1a triggers GABAergic neuronal cell fates in the retina
BMC Developmental Biology volume 7, Article number: 110 (2007)
In recent years, considerable knowledge has been gained on the molecular mechanisms underlying retinal cell fate specification. However, hitherto studies focused primarily on the six major retinal cell classes (five types of neurons of one type of glial cell), and paid little attention to the specification of different neuronal subtypes within the same cell class. In particular, the molecular machinery governing the specification of the two most abundant neurotransmitter phenotypes in the retina, GABAergic and glutamatergic, is largely unknown. In the spinal cord and cerebellum, the transcription factor Ptf1a is essential for GABAergic neuron production. In the mouse retina, Ptf1a has been shown to be involved in horizontal and most amacrine neurons differentiation.
In this study, we examined the distribution of neurotransmitter subtypes following Ptf1a gain and loss of function in the Xenopus retina. We found cell-autonomous dramatic switches between GABAergic and glutamatergic neuron production, concomitant with profound defects in the genesis of amacrine and horizontal cells, which are mainly GABAergic. Therefore, we investigated whether Ptf1a promotes the fate of these two cell types or acts directly as a GABAergic subtype determination factor. In ectodermal explant assays, Ptf1a was found to be a potent inducer of the GABAergic subtype. Moreover, clonal analysis in the retina revealed that Ptf1a overexpression leads to an increased ratio of GABAergic subtypes among the whole amacrine and horizontal cell population, highlighting its instructive capacity to promote this specific subtype of inhibitory neurons. Finally, we also found that within bipolar cells, which are typically glutamatergic interneurons, Ptf1a is able to trigger a GABAergic fate.
Altogether, our results reveal for the first time in the retina a major player in the GABAergic versus glutamatergic cell specification genetic pathway.
Five classes of retinal neurons (photoreceptors, ganglion, amacrine, horizontal and bipolar cells) and one type of glial cells (Müller cells) are produced in a stereotypical order from a multipotent pool of retinal progenitor cells [1–4]. The conserved order of appearance during development is thought to rely on the progenitor capacity to pass through several intrinsically determined competence states, during which they are capable of giving rise to only a limited subset of cell types under the influence of extrinsic signals [5, 6]. Previous studies have established that these distinct retinal cell types are specified through a combinatorial code of bHLH and homeodomain transcription factors [5, 7–9]. Importantly, these studies define these transcription factors as cell type determining factors.
Behind the simplicity of the retina, encompassing only six major cell types, lies a large diversity of retinal subtypes forming a complex and subtle structure [10, 11]. Mammalian retinas contain approximately 55 distinct subtypes of neurons, based on shape and arborization of these cells. There are many reasons to believe that each of these cell types has a distinct physiological function . Indeed, electrophysiological experiments have thus far revealed specific functions for 22 morphological distinct subtypes. A typical mammalian retina for example, contains ten to fifteen subtypes of retinal ganglion cells and nine to eleven subtypes of cone bipolar cells, based on their synaptic inputs from cone photoreceptors and their sub-laminar localization [10, 12]. Amacrine cells, which modulate synaptic activity between bipolar and ganglion cells, constitute the most diverse cell type within the retina [10, 11]. In mammals, they can be further classified into 29 different amacrine subtypes based on criteria such as sub-laminar localization (the inner plexiform layer, the ganglion cell layer and the inner part of the inner nuclear layer), morphology (e.g. starburst, parasol or midget) and neurotransmitter type (e.g. GABAergic, glycinergic, dopaminergic or serotoninergic) . In the anuran retina, the number of amacrine subtype cells stands at no less than 21 .
The current step-wise model explaining how these multiple subclasses of cells are specified, presages that retinogenic factors first determine cell types, and that another pool of transcription factors subsequently specifies retinal neuronal subtypes . Past work in developmental neurobiology has yielded significant insight into the molecular codes underlying the specification of the six major cell classes. However, little attention has been paid to the mechanisms sustaining the generation of the different neuronal subclasses in the retina. For example, targeted deletion studies have revealed that Vsx1, a paired-like homeodomain factor, and Bhlhb4, an Olig-family bHLH factor, are required for the development of cone bipolar cell and rod bipolar cell subtypes, respectively. Noteworthy, phenotypic analysis revealed that these factors are not involved in the determination of the cellular subtypes but are rather required for their late differentiation [15–17]. Targeted deletion of Bhlhb5, an Olig family bHLH factor, causes the loss of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)-producing amacrine and Type 2 OFF-cone bipolar cells. This result, together with genetic interaction studies, argues for a crucial role of Bhlhb5 in the specification of both amacrine and bipolar subtypes . However, the transcription factors responsible for the specification of the majority of retinal subtypes remain to be identified.
For the most part, the molecular cues governing fate determination for the two most abundant neurotransmitter phenotypes in the retina, GABA and glutamate, remain unexplored. Several transcription factors have however been reported as key players in this process within other regions of the central nervous system. For instance, ectopic expression of the homeobox gene Tlx3 is sufficient to repress GABAergic differentiation and induce the formation of glutamatergic cells in the spinal cord . On the other hand, the bHLH genes Mash1 and Heslike, and the homeodomain genes Nkx2.1, Dlx1/2, and Gsh1/2 are involved in the development of GABAergic neurons in the telencephalon or spinal cord [20–24]. Recently, Ptf1a (pancreas transcription factor 1a), a Twist subclass of bHLH transcription factor, has been found to be involved in driving neural precursors to differentiate into GABAergic neurons in the cerebellum and in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord [25–28]. In addition to the spinal cord, hindbrain and cerebellum, Ptf1a is also expressed in the retina during development [29–31]. Two reports studying retinal explants of knock out mice suggest that Ptf1a is involved in the genesis of horizontal and most amacrine neurons, downstream of the forkhead transcription factor Foxn4 [30, 31]. Fujitani et al. indeed found that inactivation of Ptf1a results in a complete loss of horizontal cells, a profound decrease of amacrine cells and an increase in ganglion cells . Nakkai et al. found that GABAergic and glycinergic amacrine cells, as well as horizontal cells, were completely missing in Ptf1a-knockout retinal explants . We further explored the retinal-specific roles of Ptf1a, with an emphasis on neurotransmitter phenotypes, through the use of both gain and loss of function analysis in Xenopus embryos. We found dramatic cell-autonomous switches between GABAergic and glutamatergic neuron production, correlated with profound defects in the genesis of amacrine and horizontal cells, which are mainly GABAergic. Therefore, we investigated whether Ptf1a determines the fate of these two cell types or whether it acts directly as a GABAergic subtype determining factor. We found that in animal cap assays Ptf1a is a potent GABAergic subtype inducer factor. In addition, we showed that among a particular cell type, Ptf1a overexpression leads to an increased ratio of GABAergic subtype. Together, this study reveals for the first time a key component of GABAergic versus glutamatergic cell specification genetic pathway in the retina.
Ptf1aexpression in the retina defines a subpopulation of precursor cells
The spatial and temporal distribution of Ptf1a transcripts during Xenopus laevis retinogenesis was analyzed using whole-mount in situ hybridization (Fig. 1A–H). Ptf1a expression was detected in the optic vesicle from stage 24/25 onwards (not shown). In order to finely characterize Ptf1a expression in the neural retina, we sectioned embryos transversely at key stages of retinogenesis. In the proliferating neuroepithelium, Ptf1a displayed a patchy expression pattern, with intense staining within discrete groups of cells (Fig. 1J). As retinogenesis proceeds, staining progressively declined in the central retina while remaining high in the margins, suggesting that Ptf1a mRNA expression is turned off in differentiating cells and exclusively maintained in precursor cells (Fig. 1K). Accordingly, at stage 41, when all cells in the central retina are post-mitotic, Ptf1a expression became restricted to the ciliary marginal zone (CMZ), the only retinal region where retinogenesis is still occurring post-embryonically (Fig. 1L). Noticeably, Ptf1a-positive cells were not detected in the most peripheral region of the CMZ, where stem cells reside. Altogether, these data suggest that Ptf1a mRNA is restricted to retinal precursors and features a subpopulation of retinoblasts, as inferred by its scattered distribution.
Pft1a cell-autonomously promotes amacrine and horizontal cell genesis
The Ptf1a expression profile led us to analyze whether it might function in the context of Xenopus retinogenesis. We first injected an inducible form of Ptf1a mRNA (Ptf1a-GR) into two-cell stage embryos. Protein activity was induced at stage 22 by addition of dexamethasone (DEX), and effects on retinal cell type genesis were monitored using specific markers. Ptf1a overexpressing retinas displayed substantial perturbations in laminar organization. Expression of the horizontal marker Prox1 was strongly increased following Ptf1a overexpression (Fig. 2A,B). Syntaxin staining of the inner plexiform layer (IPL) was enhanced as well, suggesting a greater density of amacrine cells (Fig. 2C,D). In contrast, highly reduced Brn3 expression (Fig. 2E,F) and virtual absence of rhodopsin staining (Fig. 2G,H) indicated that ganglion cells and photoreceptors were profoundly missing. Expression of the bipolar marker Vsx1, albeit disorganized, did not reveal any evident reduction (Fig. 2I,J). Since Vsx1 is also expressed in retinal precursors, the possibility remained that Vsx1-positive cells could be undifferentiated precursors dispersed in the central retina. However, this was excluded, as the expression of the precursor marker Xath5, was correctly restricted to the CMZ (data not shown). Finally, cell death was examined at stage 30, 35 and 39. The number of apoptotic cells in Ptf1a overexpressing retinas did not differ from that of control embryos at any stage tested (data not shown). Thus, Ptf1a gain of function drastically augments horizontal and amacrine cell production at the expense of photoreceptor and ganglion cells.
Parallel loss of function experiments were then performed using an antisense Morpholino oligonucleotide designed against the ATG-containing 5' end of Ptf1a (Ptf1a Mo; Fig. 2U–Y). Inhibition of Ptf1a resulted in complete loss of Prox1-positive horizontal cells (Fig. 2K,L) and severe decrease of syntaxin-stained amacrine fibers (Fig. 2M,N), along with strong increase of the ganglion cell marker Brn3 expression (Fig. 2O,P). Despite the significant laminar disorganization, rhodopsin and Vsx1 stainings revealed an apparent normal generation of photoreceptor and bipolar cells, respectively (Fig. 2Q–T). In contrast to the gain of function experiment, apoptosis was significantly enhanced upon Ptf1a inhibition during retinogenesis (data not shown). These results indicate that at least part of the Ptf1a knocked-down retinal precursors either undergo apoptosis or are biased towards a ganglion fate at the expense of amacrine and horizontal cell fates, similarly to previous findings in mouse retina [30, 31].
The above data suggest that Ptf1a is required for proper generation of amacrine and horizontal cells. In order to investigate whether Ptf1a acts cell autonomously, Ptf1a or a Ptf1a chimeric construct fused to the VP16 transactivation domain (Ptf1a-VP16) were overexpressed in the developing retina by in vivo lipofection at stage 17/18. GFP expressing plasmid was used as a tracer, allowing for the identification of transfected cells in stage 40/41 embryos, when most cells in the central retina are fully differentiated . Both Ptf1a constructs led to very similar changes in cell type distribution, although Ptf1a-VP16 phenotype was clearly enhanced (Fig. 3A). In agreement with two-cell stage injection experiments, Ptf1a overexpressing clones exhibited increased proportions of horizontal and amacrine cells compared to control ones (Fig. 3A–E). This was, as expected, at the expense of photoreceptors and ganglion cells. Of note, although the global proportion of cells in the ganglion cell layer was not affected, ganglion cells were significantly depleted, whereas displaced amacrine cells were drastically increased (see below and Fig. 5D,K–P). Moreover, Müller glial cells were virtually absent among Ptf1a-VP16 lipofected clones. Altogether, these data suggest that Ptf1a acts cell autonomously to bias precursor cells towards amacrine and horizontal destinies.
Ptf1apromotes a GABAergic cell fate of retinal precursor cells
Amacrine and horizontal interneurons have been described in different model organisms as the two major GABAergic populations in the retina, whereas photoreceptor, ganglion and bipolar cells are considered as mainly glutamatergic . As recent studies have highlighted a role for Ptf1a in the specification of GABAergic neurons in both the murine spinal cord  and cerebellum , we wondered whether Ptf1a might have a similar function in the retina. As expected, expression of glutamic acid decarboxylase (Gad), the rate limiting enzyme for GABA biosynthesis, was restricted to horizontal and amacrine cell layers (Fig. 4A,G). Conversely, expression of VGlut1, which encodes a glutamate transporter, could be detected in photoreceptors, bipolar and ganglion cell layers (Fig. 4D,I). Ptf1a overexpression resulted in dramatic increase of Gad staining in the retina (Fig. 4A–C) at the expense of VGlut1 expression (Fig. 4D–F). In contrast, Ptf1a knocked-down retinas exhibited severe to complete abrogation of Gad-expressing cells (Fig. 4G,H), with concomitant enlargement of the VGlut1-expressing domain (Fig. 4I,J).
Such phenotypes are consistent with the above cell type distribution data and thus raise the question of whether Ptf1a determines the fate of cell types that are mainly GABAergic or whether it directly acts as a GABAergic subtype determination factor. To further explore this second hypothesis, we tested the capacity of Ptf1a to activate Gad expression in ectodermal explants (animal caps). Similar to X-ngnr-1, Ptf1a was able to induce neurogenesis in naive animal caps, as shown by N-tubulin expression. Importantly, overexpression of Ptf1a, but not that of X-ngnr-1, resulted in a significant induction of Gad expression (Fig. 4K). On the other hand, X-ngnr-1 but not Ptf1a, strongly activated the expression of XHox11L2/Tlx3, a selector gene determining glutamatergic over GABAergic cell fates in the spinal cord  (Fig. 4K). In whole embryos, Ptf1a still behaved as a proneural gene, inducing, as X-ngnr-1, ectopic N-tubulin expression in the epidermis (Fig. 4L–N). However, only Ptf1a was able to drive Gad ectopic expression (Fig. 4O–Q). Finally, in the neural tube, the Gad expression domain was substantially extended in Ptf1a-injected embryos (Fig. 4R). Conversely, injection of Ptf1a Mo strongly reduced Gad expression in the hindbrain (Fig. 4S). These results demonstrate that Ptf1a can act as a GABAergic subtype inducing factor and suggest that it is specifically required in the retina for GABAergic cell genesis at the expense of glutamatergic neurons.
Ptf1a differentially affects subtypes of amacrine and horizontal neurons
In order to demonstrate that Ptf1a does not simply specify amacrine and horizontal cell fates but rather specifically pushes retinal precursors to adopt a GABAergic phenotype, we analyzed the proportion of GABA-positive cells within horizontal and amacrine Ptf1a-overexpressing cells, through a clonal analysis. We found that the ratio of GABAergic neurons in both cell types was largely increased compared to controls (Fig. 5A–P). Noticeably, regarding amacrine cells, this increase was essentially due to a dramatically enhanced proportion of GABA-positive displaced amacrine cells (Fig. 5B–D,K–P). This result suggests that Ptf1a has the particular function of differentially favoring GABAergic subtypes among amacrine and horizontal cells.
We next examined whether other neurotransmitter subtypes of amacrine cells were affected following Ptf1a misexpression. Injection experiments revealed that the number of serotoninergic (serotonin-immunoreactive) and dopaminergic (tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactive) amacrine cells were, like GABAergic ones, decreased following Ptf1a loss of function and increased upon overexpression (Fig. 6A–R). We also found that the number of glycine-positive cells was significantly lower in the retina of Ptf1a Mo-injected embryos (Fig. 6S,T,W). Surprisingly, however, in Ptf1a overexpressing retinas, a severe decrease of glycinergic amacrine cells could be observed (Fig. 6U,V,X). To rule out potential secondary effects resulting from impaired retinal morphogenesis, we turned to clonal analysis through in vivo lipofection. In contrast to the Ptf1a two-cell stage injection data, Ptf1a-VP16 overexpressing clones displayed a significant increase in the proportion of glycine-positive amacrine cells (50% n = 4 retinas, 176 cells versus 33% n = 5 retinas, 185 cells; p < 0.001). Thus, Ptf1a seems to be able, at least in some conditions, to favor glycinergic, dopaminergic, and serotonin-positive cell genesis, at the expense of yet unindentified other amacrine subtypes.
Ptf1a converts glutamatergic bipolar interneurons into GABAergic cells
In contrast to glutamatergic photoreceptors and ganglion cells that are extensively suppressed upon Ptf1a overexpression, bipolar cells appear largely unaffected both in two-cell stage injection and lipofection experiments (Fig. 1I–J and Fig. 3A). Regarding the global reduction of VGlut1 staining in Ptf1a-GR injected retinas (Fig. 4D–F), it is likely that a significant proportion of bipolar cells must have altered its fate towards another neurotransmitter phenotype. The existence, in physiological conditions, of a minority GABAergic bipolar subpopulation in amphibians [33, 34] led us to postulate that Ptf1a gain of function might drive bipolar precursors to acquire a GABAergic phenotype. As a first attempt to test this hypothesis, we performed double in situ hybridizations using the Vsx1 bipolar probe in combination with either the VGlut1 or Gad probes. As expected, Vsx1 staining appears to be co-localized with the VGlut1-positive layer of the INL but not with the Gad-positive one in control embryos (Fig. 7A,C). In contrast, in Ptf1a overexpressing retinas, double Vsx1/Vglut1 staining was highly reduced (Fig. 7B), while regions co-expressing both Vsx1 and Gad were apparent (Fig. 7D), suggesting that some glutamatergic bipolar cells transfated towards a GABAergic phenotype. This result could be further assessed through clonal lipofection analysis (Fig. 7E–K). Indeed, we observed a dramatic increase in the proportion of GABA-positive cells among Ptf1a-lipofected cells localized in the bipolar cell layer compared to control ones (43% versus 5%).
It has recently been shown that the Otx2 transcription factor, which is selectively expressed in a subpopulation of bipolar cells , controls identity and fate of glutamatergic progenitors of the thalamus by repressing the alternative GABAergic differentiation program . We thus wondered whether the capacity of Ptf1a to force GABAergic fate of bipolar cells might be related to effects on Otx2 expression. Ptf1a-GR injection in two-cell stage embryos indeed led to a drastic reduction of Otx2-positive cells in the outer portion of the INL (Fig. 7L–N). Consistently, clonal analysis revealed a decreased proportion of Otx2-positive cells among Ptf1a-overexpressing bipolar cells compared to a control experiment (7% versus 27%, Fig. 7O–W). Thus, Ptf1a overexpression leads to an unbalance between GABA and Otx2-positive bipolar cell subtypes.
Many transcription factors affect the diversity and numbers of distinct retinal cell types. In contrast, studies identifying molecular cues underlying retinal subtype specification are limited. We focused our attention on GABAergic inhibitory neurons and glutamatergic excitatory neurons. In the central nervous system, a balance of excitation and inhibition is essential for nearly all functions, and imbalances can result in sensory disorders. In the retina, the complex network of excitatory and inhibitory pathways contributes to edge sharpening, contrast enhancement, spatial summation, noise averaging, and other forms of signal processing. Thus far, the molecular players governing the determination of glutamatergic and GABAergic neurons in the retina have surprisingly remained unexplored. We report here on the key role of Ptf1a in this process. To reach this conclusion, the role of Ptf1a during retinogenesis was examined using both gain and loss of function approaches through different experimental strategies, including histological assessment of retinal cell types and subtypes, clonal analysis and animal cap assays.
The role of Ptf1a in the retina has been studied through its inactivation in mice and analyzed in retinal explants [30, 31]; it led to a complete loss of horizontal cells and to a profound decrease of amacrine cells, suggesting that Ptf1a plays a central role in directing retinal progenitors towards these cell fates. In our loss of function analyses in the Xenopus retina, we confirmed a severe reduction of amacrine and horizontal cells. As reported in Ptf1a-/- retinal explants, we also observed a concomitant increase of ganglion cells. Our gain of function results reinforce the idea that Ptf1a is able to bias retinal precursors towards amacrine and horizontal fates. However, Nakkai et al. found that in the Ptf1a null retina a small number of amacrine precursor cells differentiated to amacrine cells and thus proposed that Ptf1a may contribute to the specification of amacrine cell subtypes rather than to the generation of whole amacrine cells . Indeed, as discussed below, our detailed analysis of the neuronal subtype distribution in both gain and loss of function experiments, revealed that Ptf1a may play a role in neurotransmitter subtype specification rather than simply specifying amacrine and horizontal cell fates.
Past work has identified Ptf1a as the responsible gene for permanent neonatal diabetes mellitus associated with pancreatic and cerebellar agenesis . The function of Ptf1a in the cerebellum has been investigated in cerebelless mutant mice and revealed its role in defining GABAergic neuronal fates . In addition, involvement of Ptf1a in the genetic cascade specifying GABAergic over glutamatergic neurons has been established in the dorsal spinal cord . Our GABA and glutamate analysis support the hypothesis that Ptf1a also promotes a switch between GABAergic and glutamatergic fates in the retina. Through clonal analysis, we further demonstrated the instructive capacity of Ptf1a to trigger GABAergic neuron production within amacrine and horizontal cell populations. We thus propose that Ptf1a does not simply determine horizontal and amacrine interneurons but preferentially promotes formation of the GABAergic subtypes of these cells. It is likely that Ptf1a truly acts as a determining factor rather than a differentiation factor, as we found that it is sufficient to drive neuronal differentiation in both ectodermal explants and whole embryos and has the ability to change precursor fate in the retina.
Noticeably, we also found that serotoninergic and dopaminergic amacrine cells, two minority subtypes, were increased upon Ptf1a overexpression and decreased upon Ptf1a loss of function. Ptf1a may be directly required for the specification of these subtypes. Importantly, however, evidence for a dual expression of GABA and serotonin or GABA and dopamine has been reported in the retina of several species including Xenopus [38–41]. Hence, an alternative hypothesis is that Ptf1a-induced changes in the number of GABAergic cells account for the observed effects on the amount of 5-HT- and TH-positive neurons. As observed in mice [30, 31], we also found that glycinergic amacrine cell genesis was inhibited upon Ptf1a loss of function. However, a potential role of Ptf1a in determining this cell subtype remains unclear regarding our gain of function experiments. Indeed, we obtained opposite phenotypes when Ptf1a was either overexpressed following retinoblast in vivo lipofection (increase) or by two-cell stage mRNA injections (decrease). Such a discrepancy may arise from differences in dose and/or timing of Ptf1a transgene expression. As feedback loops are known to regulate amacrine cell genesis , the possibility also remains that the dramatic perturbation of the GABAergic cell population, as observed in the two cell stage injection experiments, may non cell-autonomously affect glycinergic cell production.
Using retrograde neuronal tracer experiments, it has been established that some ganglion cells in the outer half of the ganglion cell layer are GABA-positive . We thus wondered whether some of the numerous GABAergic cells found in the ganglion cell layer upon Ptf1a overexpression might actually be ganglion cells rather than displaced amacrine cells. Our GAP-GFP (a membrane bound GFP allowing to better stain neuronal fibers) staining highlighted that a few of these cells have processes resembling ganglion cell axons (data not shown), while displaced amacrine cells have neurites oriented towards the INL . Thus, although this situation remains to be quantified with a more accurate technical approach, we suspect that Ptf1a, in addition to increase the proportion of GABAergic displaced amacrine cells in the ganglion cell layer, may also increase the proportion of GABA-positive ganglion cells.
Even though retinal bipolar neurons mainly release the excitatory transmitter glutamate, evidence that certain bipolar cells contain GABA and express Gad has been reported in both mammalian and amphibian retinas [33, 34, 45, 46]. Both our double in situ experiments and clonal analysis revealed that, in a context of Ptf1a overexpression, a considerable proportion of bipolar neurons transfate towards a GABAergic phenotype. Genetic lineage tracing in mice did not reveal that some Ptf1a-expressing precursors are dedicated to bipolar cell production. However, the low number of GABAergic bipolar neurons in wild type retinas may have hindered the identification of a Ptf1a-positive bipolar lineage. Therefore, although this deserves further investigation, our data suggest that Ptf1a may have a role in specifying the GABAergic bipolar subtype. Altogether, these findings indicate that Ptf1a can act as a neuronal subtype determination factor, which instructs neural precursors to differentiate into GABAergic neurons. Our findings thus suggest that Ptf1a constitutes the first identified member of the genetic cascade responsible for GABAergic cell specification in the retina.
Several in vitro studies suggest that, in the optic vesicle, some retinal progenitors are not multipotent but are instead differentially biased towards specific cell types, such as rod and bipolar cells or amacrine and horizontal cells for instance [42, 47–49]. Molecular identification of these precursor subpopulations is largely lacking. The transcription factor FoxN4 is expressed in a restricted subset of retinal precursors and presumably confers the competence to form amacrine and horizontal cells . Ptf1a also labels a subpopulation of retinoblasts at both the levels of mRNA (this study) and protein expression [30, 31]. Our data suggest that Ptf1a-expressing precursors are biased towards a GABAergic fate. As we showed that Ptf1a mRNA starts to be detectable in discrete groups of proliferating precursors as soon as the optic vesicle forms, it is likely that the segregation of a population fated to the GABAergic subtype occurs early in retinal development. This does not fit with the step-wise model supporting the view that subtype specification follows cell class determination. For instance, in the mouse retina it has been proposed that pan-bipolar cells are first specified by Chx10, Math3 and Mash1 and that specification of OFF and ON cone subtypes takes place subsequently under the influence of another set of transcription factors . However, our hypothesis that GABAergic fate specification occurs early in retinogenesis is substantiated by several lineage and transplantation experiments demonstrating that some blastomeres are intrinsically biased, as early as during the early cleavage stage, to produce subsets of neurotransmitter subtypes of amacrine cells [49, 51]. Moreover, it has recently been reported that Rx1 and Pax6 misexpression at the eye field stage differentially affects amacrine subtypes proportions, suggesting that these interneurons are not all specified by a single genetic program . Together with our present work, these findings support the hypothesis that at least some neurotransmitter subtypes are specified by a combinatorial code of transcription factors during early eye development. Importantly, we were able to highlight a role of Ptf1a in GABAergic neuron specification as we analyzed various subtypes of retinal cells. In this regard, it is likely that other transcription factors, described so far as cell type inducers, may actually have a role in the formation of different retinal neurotransmitter subtypes. It would therefore be important to re-evaluate the effects of key components of retinal cell fate specification in the context of cell subtype determination. Such future work would be critical to understand the molecular events that generate the myriad of different cell subtypes in the retina.
Altogether, our gain and loss of function data identify Ptf1a as a determining factor for retinal GABAergic subtypes neurons as opposed to a determining factor for cell types. Further work examining neurotransmitter cell subtypes should expand our knowledge about retinogenesis, and permit in particular to uncover the genetic network sustaining GABAergic/glutamatergic determination in the retina.
Constructs and Morpholinos
pCS2+-X-ngnr-1, pCS2+-X-ngnr-1-GR , pCS2+-Ptf1a and pCS2+-Ptf1a-GR  have previously been described. X-ngnr-1-GR and Ptf1a-GR encode glucocorticoid inducible chimeric morphants. Protein activity was induced with 4 μg/ml dexamethasone (DEX, Sigma) in the embryo medium. The pCS2+-Ptf1a-VP16 encodes a Ptf1a variant where the VP16 transactivation domain is fused to the carboxylterminus of Ptf1a. The Ptf1a (Ptf1a Mo; ) and control (Ctrl Mo, 5 mismatches; Fig. 2U) Morpholino (Mo) oligonucleotides were purchased from GeneTools (LLC). Two types of Mo were used: crude Mo (for blastomere injection experiments), and "Special Delivery" Mo, where the non-ionic crude Morpholinos are paired to a complementary carrier DNA (for lipofection experiments) [54, 55]. The region complementary to the Ptf1a Mo (encompassing 5' untranslated and N-terminal-coding regions of Ptf1a) was amplified by PCR from pBK-CMV Ptf1a and cloned in frame downstream of the GFP coding sequence in pCS2 plasmid (pCS2+-Ptf1a(5')-GFP; Fig. 2U).
Embryos, microinjections and animal cap explants
Xenopus laevis embryos were obtained by hormone-induced egg laying and in vitro fertilization by conventional methods. Capped sense RNAs were prepared from CS2 plasmids after NotI digestion and transcribed using the mMessage mMachine™ SP6 kit (Ambion). RNAs were injected in a volume of 5 nl at a concentration of 100–150 pg/nl into two of two or one of two blastomeres of embryos at the two-cell stage. GFP RNA (100 pg) co-injection was used to visualize injected cells. Morpholino (Mo) injections were performed as indicated by the manufacturer (GeneTools, LLC). Animal cap explants and real-time RT-PCR analysis were performed as previously described . The following primers pairs were used: ODC ; N-tubulin ; Gad for: ATGGGCGTCTTACTCCAATG, rev: ATGTCTACATGGCGACCACCACA; Hox11L2 for: GCCAACAAGTACAAGTGCACAG, rev: CAGGAGCCAGACTCACATTGAC.
pCS2-GFP, pCS2-Ptf1a and pCS2-Ptf1a-VP16 were transfected at stage 18 into the presumptive region of the retina as previously described [55, 59]. Embryos were fixed at stage 40/41 and cryostat sectioned (12 μm). GFP-positive cells were counted and cell types were identified based upon their laminar position and morphology . In some cases, the gap-GFP plasmid (a gift from E. Amaya), which encodes a membrane bound GFP, was used to improve neuronal fiber staining in order to better assess retinal cell type identity.
Immunohistochemistry and Tunnel assay
Immunohistochemistry was performed as described previously , using rabbit polyclonal or mouse monoclonal anti-GFP (Molecular Probe), rabbit polyclonal anti-GABA (ImmunoStar), rabbit polyclonal anti-Glycine (ImmunoSolution), rabbit polyclonal anti-serotonin (Immunostar), mouse monoclonal anti-tyrosine hydroxylase (Immunostar), mouse monoclonal anti-syntaxin (Sigma), rabbit polyclonal anti-Otx2 , mouse monoclonal anti-rhodopsin (clone R2–12, a gift from N. Colley), and anti-mouse or anti-rabbit fluorescent secondary antibodies (Alexa, Molecular Probes). Cell nuclei were counterstained with Hoechst (Sigma). Detection of cell apoptosis was carried out with the DeadEnd fluorometric TUNEL system (Promega). Fluorescent stainings were visualized with a Leica HBO100 microscope. Images were then captured using a QICAM camera (QIMAGING) and processed with Adobe Photoshop 7.0 software. Shown in figures are representative data from one experiment that has been performed at least in duplicate.
Digoxigenin- or fluorescein-labelled antisense RNA probes, Ptf1a , Gad , XVGlut1 , XVsx1 , Brn3.0 , Prox1 (a gift from F. Cremisi) and Xath5  were generated according to the manufacturer's instructions (Roche). Whole mount in situ hybridization was carried out as previously described , with an additional step of bleaching just before the proteinase K treatment . For double in situ hybridization, XVsx1 fluorescein-labeled probes were first revealed with Fast red substrate (Roche). Embryos were then treated in 0.1 M Glycine-HCl pH 2.2 for 10 minutes and processed for Gad or XVGlut1 digoxigenin-labeled probe revelation using NBT/BCIP. Embryos were then vibratome sectioned (50 μm).
Holt CE, Bertsch TW, Ellis HM, Harris WA: Cellular determination in the Xenopus retina is independent of lineage and birth date. Neuron. 1988, 1: 15-26.
Wetts R, Fraser SE: Multipotent precursors can give rise to all major cell types of the frog retina. Science. 1988, 239: 1142-5.
Young RW: Cell differentiation in the retina of the mouse. Anat Rec. 1985, 212: 199-205.
Cepko CL, Austin CP, Yang X, Alexiades M, Ezzeddine D: Cell fate determination in the vertebrate retina. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1996, 93: 589-95.
Livesey FJ, Cepko CL: Vertebrate neural cell-fate determination: lessons from the retina. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2001, 2: 109-18.
Kageyama R, Ohtsuka T, Hatakeyama J, Ohsawa R: Roles of bHLH genes in neural stem cell differentiation. Exp Cell Res. 2005, 306: 343-8.
Wang JC, Harris WA: The role of combinational coding by homeodomain and bHLH transcription factors in retinal cell fate specification. Dev Biol. 2005, 285: 101-15.
Cepko CL: The roles of intrinsic and extrinsic cues and bHLH genes in the determination of retinal cell fates. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 1999, 9: 37-46.
Hatakeyama J, Kageyama R: Retinal cell fate determination and bHLH factors. Semin Cell Dev Biol. 2004, 15: 83-9.
Masland RH: The fundamental plan of the retina. Nat Neurosci. 2001, 4: 877-86.
Masland RH: Neuronal diversity in the retina. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 2001, 11: 431-6.
Ghosh KK, Bujan S, Haverkamp S, Feigenspan A, Wassle H: Types of bipolar cells in the mouse retina. J Comp Neurol. 2004, 469: 70-82.
Vigh J, Banvolgyi T, Wilhelm M: Amacrine cells of the anuran retina: morphology, chemical neuroanatomy, and physiology. Microsc Res Tech. 2000, 50: 373-83.
Agathocleous M, Harris W: Cell determination. Retinal Development. Edited by: Sernagor E, Eglen S, Harris W, Wong R. 2006, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 75-98.
Chow RL, Volgyi B, Szilard RK, Ng D, McKerlie C, Bloomfield SA, Birch DG, McInnes RR: Control of late off-center cone bipolar cell differentiation and visual signaling by the homeobox gene Vsx1. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2004, 101: 1754-9.
Ohtoshi A, Wang SW, Maeda H, Saszik SM, Frishman LJ, Klein WH, Behringer RR: Regulation of retinal cone bipolar cell differentiation and photopic vision by the CVC homeobox gene Vsx1. Curr Biol. 2004, 14: 530-6.
Bramblett DE, Pennesi ME, Wu SM, Tsai MJ: The transcription factor Bhlhb4 is required for rod bipolar cell maturation. Neuron. 2004, 43: 779-93.
Feng L, Xie X, Joshi PS, Yang Z, Shibasaki K, Chow RL, Gan L: Requirement for Bhlhb5 in the specification of amacrine and cone bipolar subtypes in mouse retina. Development. 2006, 133: 4815-25.
Cheng L, Arata A, Mizuguchi R, Qian Y, Karunaratne A, Gray PA, Arata S, Shirasawa S, Bouchard M, Luo P, Chen CL, Busslinger M, Goulding M, Onimaru H, Ma Q: Tlx3 and Tlx1 are post-mitotic selector genes determining glutamatergic over GABAergic cell fates. Nat Neurosci. 2004, 7: 510-7.
Anderson DJ, Groves A, Lo L, Ma Q, Rao M, Shah NM, Sommer L: Cell lineage determination and the control of neuronal identity in the neural crest. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol. 1997, 62: 493-504.
Casarosa S, Fode C, Guillemot F: Mash1 regulates neurogenesis in the ventral telencephalon. Development. 1999, 126: 525-34.
Sussel L, Marin O, Kimura S, Rubenstein JL: Loss of Nkx2.1 homeobox gene function results in a ventral to dorsal molecular respecification within the basal telencephalon: evidence for a transformation of the pallidum into the striatum. Development. 1999, 126: 3359-70.
Mizuguchi R, Kriks S, Cordes R, Gossler A, Ma Q, Goulding M: Ascl1 and Gsh1/2 control inhibitory and excitatory cell fate in spinal sensory interneurons. Nat Neurosci. 2006, 9: 770-8.
Miyoshi G, Bessho Y, Yamada S, Kageyama R: Identification of a novel basic helix-loop-helix gene, Heslike, and its role in GABAergic neurogenesis. J Neurosci. 2004, 24: 3672-82.
Glasgow SM, Henke RM, Macdonald RJ, Wright CV, Johnson JE: Ptf1a determines GABAergic over glutamatergic neuronal cell fate in the spinal cord dorsal horn. Development. 2005, 132: 5461-9.
Hoshino M, Nakamura S, Mori K, Kawauchi T, Terao M, Nishimura YV, Fukuda A, Fuse T, Matsuo N, Sone M, Watanabe M, Bito H, Terashima T, Wright CV, Kawaguchi Y, Nakao K, Nabeshima Y: Ptf1a, a bHLH transcriptional gene, defines GABAergic neuronal fates in cerebellum. Neuron. 2005, 47: 201-13.
Pascual M, Abasolo I, Mingorance-Le Meur A, Martinez A, Del Rio JA, Wright CV, Real FX, Soriano E: Cerebellar GABAergic progenitors adopt an external granule cell-like phenotype in the absence of Ptf1a transcription factor expression. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2007, 104: 5193-8.
Hoshino M: Molecular machinery governing GABAergic neuron specification in the cerebellum. Cerebellum. 2006, 5: 193-8.
Afelik S, Chen Y, Pieler T: Combined ectopic expression of Pdx1 and Ptf1a/p48 results in the stable conversion of posterior endoderm into endocrine and exocrine pancreatic tissue. Genes Dev. 2006, 20: 1441-6.
Fujitani Y, Fujitani S, Luo H, Qiu F, Burlison J, Long Q, Kawaguchi Y, Edlund H, MacDonald RJ, Furukawa T, Fujikado T, Magnuson MA, Xiang M, Wright CV: Ptf1a determines horizontal and amacrine cell fates during mouse retinal development. Development. 2006, 133: 4439-50.
Nakhai H, Sel S, Favor J, Mendoza-Torres L, Paulsen F, Duncker GI, Schmid RM: Ptf1a is essential for the differentiation of GABAergic and glycinergic amacrine cells and horizontal cells in the mouse retina. Development. 2007
Yang XL: Characterization of receptors for glutamate and GABA in retinal neurons. Prog Neurobiol. 2004, 73: 127-50.
Yang CY, Yazulla S: Glutamate-, GABA-, and GAD-immunoreactivities co-localize in bipolar cells of tiger salamander retina. Vis Neurosci. 1994, 11: 1193-203.
Yang CY: gamma-aminobutyric acid transporter-mediated current from bipolar cells in tiger salamander retinal slices. Vision Res. 1998, 38: 2521-6.
Decembrini S, Andreazzoli M, Vignali R, Barsacchi G, Cremisi F: Timing the generation of distinct retinal cells by homeobox proteins. PLoS Biol. 2006, 4: e272-
Puelles E, Acampora D, Gogoi R, Tuorto F, Papalia A, Guillemot F, Ang SL, Simeone A: Otx2 controls identity and fate of glutamatergic progenitors of the thalamus by repressing GABAergic differentiation. J Neurosci. 2006, 26: 5955-64.
Sellick GS, Barker KT, Stolte-Dijkstra I, Fleischmann C, Coleman RJ, Garrett C, Gloyn AL, Edghill EL, Hattersley AT, Wellauer PK, Goodwin G, Houlston RS: Mutations in PTF1A cause pancreatic and cerebellar agenesis. Nat Genet. 2004, 36: 1301-5.
Wassle H, Chun MH: Dopaminergic and indoleamine-accumulating amacrine cells express GABA-like immunoreactivity in the cat retina. J Neurosci. 1988, 8: 3383-94.
Nguyen-Legros J, Versaux-Botteri C, Savy C: Dopaminergic and GABAergic retinal cell populations in mammals. Microsc Res Tech. 1997, 36: 26-42.
Zhu BS, Straznicky C: Co-localization of serotonin and GABA in neurons of the Xenopus laevis retina. Anat Embryol (Berl). 1993, 187: 549-55.
Huang S, Moody SA: Dual expression of GABA or serotonin and dopamine in Xenopus amacrine cells is transient and may be regulated by laminar cues. Vis Neurosci. 1998, 15: 969-77.
Belliveau MJ, Cepko CL: Extrinsic and intrinsic factors control the genesis of amacrine and cone cells in the rat retina. Development. 1999, 126: 555-66.
da Costa BL, Hokoc JN, Pinaud RR, Gattass R: GABAergic retinocollicular projection in the New World monkey Cebus apella. Neuroreport. 1997, 8: 1797-802.
Godinho L, Mumm JS, Williams PR, Schroeter EH, Koerber A, Park SW, Leach SD, Wong RO: Targeting of amacrine cell neurites to appropriate synaptic laminae in the developing zebrafish retina. Development. 2005, 132: 5069-79.
Freed MA: GABAergic circuits in the mammalian retina. Prog Brain Res. 1992, 90: 107-31.
Kao YH, Lassova L, Bar-Yehuda T, Edwards RH, Sterling P, Vardi N: Evidence that certain retinal bipolar cells use both glutamate and GABA. J Comp Neurol. 2004, 478: 207-18.
Jensen AM, Raff MC: Continuous observation of multipotential retinal progenitor cells in clonal density culture. Dev Biol. 1997, 188: 267-79.
Alexiades MR, Cepko CL: Subsets of retinal progenitors display temporally regulated and distinct biases in the fates of their progeny. Development. 1997, 124: 1119-31.
Zaghloul NA, Yan B, Moody SA: Step-wise specification of retinal stem cells during normal embryogenesis. Biol Cell. 2005, 97: 321-37.
Li S, Mo Z, Yang X, Price SM, Shen MM, Xiang M: Foxn4 controls the genesis of amacrine and horizontal cells by retinal progenitors. Neuron. 2004, 43: 795-807.
Moody SA, Chow I, Huang S: Intrinsic bias and lineage restriction in the phenotype determination of dopamine and neuropeptide Y amacrine cells. J Neurosci. 2000, 20: 3244-53.
Zaghloul NA, Moody SA: Changes in Rx1 and Pax6 activity at eye field stages differentially alter the production of amacrine neurotransmitter subtypes in Xenopus. Mol Vis. 2007, 13: 86-95.
Perron M, Opdecamp K, Butler K, Harris WA, Bellefroid EJ: X-ngnr-1 and Xath3 promote ectopic expression of sensory neuron markers in the neurula ectoderm and have distinct inducing properties in the retina. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1999, 96: 14996-5001.
Morcos PA: Achieving efficient delivery of morpholino oligos in cultured cells. Genesis. 2001, 30: 94-102.
Ohnuma S, Mann F, Boy S, Perron M, Harris WA: Lipofection strategy for the study of Xenopus retinal development. Methods. 2002, 28: 411-9.
Klisch TJ, Souopgui J, Juergens K, Rust B, Pieler T, Henningfeld KA: Mxi1 is essential for neurogenesis in Xenopus and acts by bridging the pan-neural and proneural genes. Dev Biol. 2006, 292: 470-85.
Heasman J, Kofron M, Wylie C: Beta-catenin signaling activity dissected in the early Xenopus embryo: a novel antisense approach. Dev Biol. 2000, 222: 124-34.
Good PJ, Richter K, Dawid IB: The sequence of a nervous system-specific, class II beta-tubulin gene from Xenopus laevis. Nucleic Acids Res. 1989, 17: 8000-
Holt CE, Garlick N, Cornel E: Lipofection of cDNAs in the embryonic vertebrate central nervous system. Neuron. 1990, 4: 203-14.
Dorsky RI, Rapaport DH, Harris WA: Xotch inhibits cell differentiation in the Xenopus retina. Neuron. 1995, 14: 487-96.
Perron M, Boy S, Amato MA, Viczian A, Koebernick K, Pieler T, Harris WA: A novel function for Hedgehog signalling in retinal pigment epithelium differentiation. Development. 2003, 130: 1565-77.
Li M, Sipe CW, Hoke K, August LL, Wright MA, Saha MS: The role of early lineage in GABAergic and glutamatergic cell fate determination in Xenopus laevis. J Comp Neurol. 2006, 495: 645-57.
D'Autilia S, Decembrini S, Casarosa S, He RQ, Barsacchi G, Cremisi F, Andreazzoli M: Cloning and developmental expression of the Xenopus homeobox gene Xvsx1. Dev Genes Evol. 2006, 216: 829-834.
Hirsch N, Harris WA: Xenopus Brn-3.0, a POU-domain gene expressed in the developing retina and tectum. Not regulated by innervation. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 1997, 38: 960-9.
Kanekar S, Perron M, Dorsky R, Harris WA, Jan LY, Jan YN, Vetter ML: Xath5 participates in a network of bHLH genes in the developing Xenopus retina. Neuron. 1997, 19: 981-94.
Pollet N, Delius H, Niehrs C: In situ analysis of gene expression in Xenopus embryos. C R Biol. 2003, 326: 1011-7.
Broadbent J, Read EM: Wholemount in situ hybridization of Xenopus and zebrafish embryos. Methods Mol Biol. 1999, 127: 57-67.
We thank M. Saha; E. Amaya and F. Cremisi for sending plasmids. We also thank William A. Harris for critical reading of the manuscript. We are grateful to J. Hamdache and K. Ditter for technical assistance and to Y. Aoki for preliminary experiments. This work was supported by the ARC and ANR (to M.P.) and the DFG, CMP (to T.P. and K.A.H).
The author(s) declares that there are no competing interests.
JPD, ML, MR and MP conducted most of the experimental work. KH carried out animal cap assays and part of ectopic overexpression experiments. KP performed in situ hybridizations. SA generated Ptf1a expression vectors. MP and TP conceived the study. ML and MP designed and coordinated the work and wrote the manuscript. JPD, KH and TP contributed to critical reading of the manuscript and all authors read and approved its final version.
Jean-Philippe Dullin, Morgane Locker, Mélodie Robach contributed equally to this work.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Dullin, J., Locker, M., Robach, M. et al. Ptf1a triggers GABAergic neuronal cell fates in the retina. BMC Dev Biol 7, 110 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-213X-7-110
- Bipolar Cell
- Amacrine Cell
- Ganglion Cell Layer
- Horizontal Cell