Cytomegalovirus induces abnormal chondrogenesis and osteogenesis during embryonic mandibular development

Human clinical studies and mouse models clearly demonstrate that cytomegalovirus (CMV) disrupts normal organ and tissue development. It is established that about 2% of live born infants are congenitally infected with active CMV, making CMV one of the most common causes of major birth defects in humans [1, 2]. CMV, an enveloped, double-stranded DNA betaherpesvirus, is species-specific and has a slow replication cycle. In congenitally-infected newborns, CMV establishes a long-lasting persistence; active CMV infection in children can last for months and even years after birth before termination of productive infection and establishment of latency [3]. Presently, little is known about the mechanism(s) underlying CMV-induced congenital malformations.

Mouse CMV (mCMV) has many features in common with human CMV (hCMV). Thus, the mouse model has been widely employed for studying the pathogenesis associated with acute, latent, and recurrent infections [4]. CMV infection of embryonic development induces substantial fetal loss, fetal growth retardation, and fetal dysmorphogenesis, particularly of the craniofacial complex (brain and branchial arches) [5–8]. Importantly, Tsutsui [9] found that viral-antigen positive cells were abundant in the mesenchyme of the oral and nasal cavities, and in the mesenchyme of the brain, postulating that mesenchymal infection is the critical step in disrupting organogenesis. If so, oral-facial organogenesis, which is highly dependent on mesenchymal integrity and epithelial-mesenchymal interactions, would be particularly vulnerable to CMV infection. Recent studies in our laboratory demonstrate that first branchial arch derivatives (submandibular salivary glands and teeth) are vulnerable to CMV infection during critical stages of their organogenesis, and that CMV has a particular tropism for neural crest-derived mesenchyme (NCM) [10, 11].

Branchial arch formation and differentiation is the sine qua non of proper oral-facial development. Branchial arches form as paired mesodermal thickenings in the lateral and ventrolateral pharyngeal walls of the early embryo (E8.5 in mice). Cranial neural crest cells migrate ventrally into the primitive arches from the caudal regions of the developing brain [12–14]. With proliferation of the NCM, the well-defined pairs of branchial arches become visible externally. Of particular importance to oral-facial development, is the first branchial arch which gives rise to the maxilla, palate, teeth, mandible, salivary glands, and the anterior two-thirds of the tongue. The first branchial arch develops as two processes, the smaller maxillary process and the larger mandibular process. The mandibular process (MAN) of the first branchial arch gives rise to the lower jaw. The paired MANs merge with one another at approximately E9 in mice, shortly after they become externally apparent. Cranial neural crest cells generate the majority of MAN mesenchymal cells which differentiate into a wide variety of derivatives, including cartilages, bones, connective tissues, tooth papilla and smooth muscles [12–14].

MAN development is dependent on the presence of Meckel's cartilage which serves as a template for mandibular bone formation, as well as contributing to part of the mandibular bone [15–18]. Meckel's cartilage formation is initiated by the condensation of neural crest-derived prechondrogenic cells, which differentiate into chondrocytes and gives rise to the characteristic rod-shaped cartilage. The cartilage grows anteriorly and posteriorly to develop into a "wish-bone-like" structure, with NCM-derived prechondrocytes being found at the chondrogenic front. Although cranial neural crest-derived and non neural crest-derived cells contribute to Meckel's cartilage [13, 19], it has become apparent that neural crest-derived cells play the primary role in Meckel's cartilage initiation, growth and chondrogenesis (see review [20]).

Meckel's cartilage serves as the primordium of the mandible and middle ear ossicles which differentiate from 3 distinct regions: the distal region which contributes to mandibular bone development and undergoes endochondral-like ossification to give rise to the mandibular symphysis; the middle region which serves as the template for mandibular membranous bone formation; and the most proximal region which undergoes endochondral ossification to give rise to the malleus and incus [15, 21–23]. Thus, the mandibular bone, a cranial NCM derivative [13], is formed by both endochondral ossification of Meckel's cartilage [18, 24, 25] and intramembranous ossification around Meckel's cartilage [21, 22]. The coronoid, condylar and angular cartilages, classified as secondary cartilages, undergo endochondral ossification in conjunction with mandibular ossification [26].

Active mCMV infection of embryonic mouse Canalicular stage submandibular salivary glands or Cap stage mandibular first molars in vitro induces severely abnormal salivary gland and tooth phenotypes [10, 11]. MCMV-infected salivary glands are significantly smaller and exhibit atypical ductal epithelial hyperplasia, apparent epithelial-mesenchymal transformation, and oncocytic-like stromal cell metaplasia; mCMV infection induces developmentally-delayed, dysmorphic molars characterized by shallow, broad and misshapen cusps, infected and affected dental papilla mesenchyme, poorly differentiated odontoblasts and ameloblasts, and diminished enamel and dentin matrix. Genomic and protein analyses indicate that the mCMV-induced pathogenesis is primarily mediated through NF-κB signaling and that there appears to be an unusual interaction between abnormal NCM cells and corresponding extracellular matrix (ECM) [10, 11].

Early embryos are barely susceptible to CMV infection, and the extant evidence suggests that the differentiation program needs to be well underway for embryonic tissues to be susceptible to viral infection and viral-induced pathology (see review, [9]). Still, it is unclear whether first branchial arch mesenchymal cells are susceptible to mCMV infection prior to differentiation of skeletal elements. To address this, we used a chemically-defined organ culture system to investigate the effect of mCMV infection on embryonic MAN morphogenesis and differentiation of skeletal elements. Active infection of embryonic day 11 (E11) predifferentiated MANs results in micrognathia consequent to decreased Meckel's cartilage chondrogenesis and mandibular osteogenesis. We also demonstrate that mCMV infection induced changes in important components of relevant signal transduction pathways.

To determine the effect of active mCMV infection on embryonic MAN morphogenesis, E11 mandibular processes (MANs) were cultured in the presence or absence of 100,000 PFU/ml lacZ-labeled mCMV for 24 hrs [11] and then in control medium for an additional 2–15 days using a chemically-defined organ culture system [10, 11, 18, 27]. We chose E11 MANs since no visible chondroprogenitor and osteoprogenitor mesenchymal condensations are seen in these primordia [18]. MCMV infection very early on negatively affects MAN morphogenesis, inducing a significant ~30% (P < 0.0001) decrease in size on day 3 (E11 + 3) of culture compared to controls; this significant ~30% significant size reduction persists on day 6 (E11 + 6) (P < 0.0001) and day 10 (E11 + 10) (P < 0.0001) of culture. The MAN hypoplasia (micrognathia) is consequent to reduced chondrogenesis and osteogenesis, and associated with microglossia (compare Figs. 1C, D to 1A, B and 2C to 2A).

Normally, after 10 days in culture (E11 + 10), Meckel's cartilage displays the characteristic 'wishbone-like' cartilaginous structure completely stained with Alcian blue, mandibular bone is weakly stained with Alizarin red and the mandibular condyle (a secondary cartilage) is stained with Alcian blue (Fig. 1A). In contrast, mCMV-infected E11 + 10 MANs exhibit skeletal defects. Although a cartilaginous 'wishbone-like' Meckel's cartilage is seen, a substantially smaller, dysmorphic cartilage with reduced Alcian blue staining is seen (Fig. 1C). We also find a notable decrease in Alizarin red-stained mandibular bone and Alcian blue-stained mandibular condyle (Fig. 1C).

Histological analysis demonstrates that viral infection interrupts chondrogenesis and ossification, resulting in a bent Meckel's cartilage with misaligned chondrocytes, a disorganized periochondrium, less mandibular bone ossification as indicated by a marked decrease in acidophilic trabecular bone matrix (osteoid), and reduced condylar development (compare Figs. 1D to 1B, 2C to 2A, 2D to 2B). The major cytological differences between mCMV-infected and control E11 + 10 MANs are found in mesenchymal stromal cells which are predominantly derived from cranial neural crest [12–14]. MCMV-infected MANs are characterized by stromal hypercellularity and altered mesenchymal cytology (Figs. 1D, 2C). Clusters of large basophilic, pleiomorphic cells which are hyperchromatic and exhibit increased nuclear-to-cytoplasm ratios are found in Meckel's cartilage perichondrium and in the peripherally-localized stromal cells surrounding Meckel's cartilage, mandibular bone and condyle (Figs. 1D, 2C). This aberrant cellular phenotype is also seen in mandibular osteoblasts and periostial cells (compare Fig. 2D to 2B).

To identify which cells are infected by mCMV, we determined the cell-specific localization of viral inclusion bodies (Figs. 2C, D), lacZ-tagged mCMV (β-galactosidase) expression (Fig. 2E) and viral immediate early protein 1 (IE1) (Fig. 2F). MCMV infection is found in stromal cells, Meckel's cartilage perichondrial cells, and mandibular osteoblasts and periostial cells. In contrast, mCMV is absent from all cartilages (Meckel's and condylar) and oral epithelium (data not shown).

By day 16 of culture (E11 + 16), chondrogenesis and osteogenesis has progressed in both control and mCMV-infected MANs (Fig. 3), with the smaller, abnormal Meckel's cartilage and mandibular bone phenotypes persisting in the presence of viral infection (compare Fig. 3B to 3A). In addition, mCMV infection results in a dysmorphic mandibular condyle, a secondary cartilage which undergoes endochondral ossification [28]. As shown in Figure 3C, the control E11 + 16 condylar process has formed a growth plate-like structure characterized by the zonation typical of endochondral ossification: mesenchymal/progenitor cell layer, a flattened chondrocyte layer, a zone of hypertrophying chondrocytes and an erosion zone comprised of an acidophilic trabecular bony matrix secreted by invading osteoblasts [29–32]. In contrast, the mCMV-infected condyle is smaller and atrophic, with the typical zonation being absent and a marked reduction in endochondral ossification (compare Fig. 3D to 3C). The chondroid region consists of dysmorphic chondroblasts/chondrocytes, with less distinct cell-to-cell borders and increased matrix. The cellular stroma is composed of large, pleiomorphic and basophilic affected and virally-infected (with inclusion bodies) cells which exhibit atypical morphology and increased nuclear-to-cytoplasm ratios. In some areas, the abnormal affected and infected stromal cells appear to invade the perichondrial/periosteal layer, migrating into the mineralized tissue to form osteoblasts.

mCMV-induced changes in cell signaling proteins

Gene targeting studies have conclusively demonstrated that multiple growth and transcription factors belonging to several signaling families, including MSX, TGF-β, BMP, FGF, Hedgehog (Hh) and Wnt, regulate mandibular morphogenesis and the differentiation of its skeletal elements (see reviews, [20, 33, 34]). To begin to identify the mechanism underlying mCMV-induced mandibular pathogenesis, we investigated the cell-specific in situ protein expression and localization of sentinel components of cell signaling pathways altered by mCMV infection in embryonic salivary glands and teeth [10, 11] or involved in Meckel's cartilage and mandibular bone morphogenesis.

Fibronectin (FN) is an extracellular matrix (ECM) component shown to play important roles in craniofacial cartilage and bone formation (see reviews, [16, 35]). FN acts as an adhesion molecule to mediate skeletal progenitor mesenchymal cell condensations which are essential for chondrogenesis and osteogenesis, as well as an extracellular molecule involved in regulating cell-extracellular interactions. Prior to signs of mesenchymal cell aggregation in the mandibular process, fibronectin deposition is seen in a nonrandom pattern resembling the future Meckel's cartilage primordium [36]. Given our observations that mCMV infection induced notable changes in the spatial distribution of FN in embryonic mouse salivary glands and mandibular first molars [10, 11], also mandibular arch derivatives, we compared the cell-specific localization of FN in mCMV-infected and uninfected (control) E11 + 10 MANs. In controls, FN is seen on Meckel's cartilage chondroblasts in a honeycomb pattern and more weakly in the perichondrium (Fig. 4A); it is also diffusely distributed throughout the ECM (Fig. 4C). In contrast, mCMV-infected MANs exhibit intense FN immunostain in Meckel's cartilage perichondrium and more weakly on misaligned chondrocytes (compare Fig. 4B to 4A). The most dramatic difference is the aberrant localization of FN surrounding individual cytomegalic stromal cells (compare Figs. 4B, D to 4A, C). This abnormal localization pattern likely interrupts cell-cell and cell-matrix interaction required for normal morphogenesis and differentiation.

mCMV and Shh signaling

Members of the hedgehog (Hh) family, including sonic hedgehog (Shh) and Indian hedgehog (Ihh), play pivotal roles during mandibular morphogenesis and the development of its skeletal elements [18, 32, 48–51]. The observation of mandibular aplasia in E15.5 and older Shh null mice indicates that Shh is essential for mandibular development [18]. Shh has also been shown to promote NCM differentiation into chondrocytes [51]. In addition, since Shh is a positively-regulated RelA response gene [52] and CMV upregulates RelA expression [10, 46, 47], it is reasonable to postulate that that mCMV infection would stimulate changes in Shh protein expression. Thus, we compared the cell-specific distribution of Shh protein in mCMV-infected and uninfected E11 + 10 MANs and identified notable differences (compare Figs. 5B, D to 5A, C). With mCMV infection, Shh is seen in cytomegalic stromal cells surrounding Meckel's (Fig. 5B) and condylar (data not shown) cartilages, as well as in the periphery, but is absent from both cartilages (Fig. 5B; data not shown). In contrast, Shh is found in control Meckel's (Fig. 5A) and condylar chondrocytes (data not shown) but not in surrounding and peripherally-localized stromal cells. MCMV infection also induced a substantial reduction in immunodetectable Shh protein in mandibular bone compared to control (compare Fig. 5D to 5C).

Active mCMV infection of E11 undifferentiated mandibular processes (MANs) in vitro induced mandibular hypoplasia consequent to decreased Meckel's cartilage chondrogenesis and mandibular osteogenesis. The mCMV-infected MANs exhibit developmentally-delayed, misshapen Meckel's cartilages with misaligned chondrocytes and disorganized perichondria; decreased mandibular bone ossification and condylar formation; and abnormal stromal cellularity. Since MAN mesenchyme and skeletal elements are primarily derived from cranial neural crest cells [12–14], our analysis of viral distribution indicates that mCMV primarily infects NCM cells and derivatives (i.e. stromal cells, Meckel's cartilage perichondrium, mandibular bone and condylar osteoblasts/periostium). These results are consistent with our prior observations in other first branchial arch derivatives (salivary glands and teeth) that mCMV has a particular tropism for neural crest-derived mesenchymal cells [10, 11]. The absence of mCMV infection in abnormal Meckel's and condylar cartilages and a subset of atypical mesenchymal cells suggests that, as in mCMV-infected glands and molars, paracrine factors likely mediate the viral effect on surrounding uninfected cells. Furthermore, perichondrial cells surrounding cartilages synthesize factors which regulate cell proliferation and differentiation during chondrogenesis [54, 59]. Thus, it is likely that mCMV-induced cartilaginous defects are due to changes in essential signaling factors secreted by virally-infected perichondrial cells. Moreover, since perichondrial cells are infected, it is unclear why mCMV did not infect Meckel's cartilage and condylar chondrocytes even though they are also derived from cranial neural crest cells. One possible explanation is that the biochemical program of chondrocytes is not permissive for mCMV infection and replication.

Chondrogenesis and osteogenesis are complex processes which involve several different phases, including chondroprogentior or osteoprogenitor mesenchymal cell condensation and overt differentiation of chondroblasts, chondrocytes and osteoblasts (see reviews, [16, 35]). Condensation, the earliest sign of the initiation of skeletogenesis, is a critical step for both chondrogenesis and osteogenesis which occurs when a previously dispersed population of mesenchymal cells forms an aggregation (condensation). Following condensation, cell-cell communications and interactions with ECM molecules are required for subsequent skeletogenesis. Thus, the ECM functions as both an adhesive molecule during initial condensation and a mediator of cell-matrix interactions during chondrogenesis and osteogenesis.

FN, an ECM component, has been shown to mediate mesenchymal cell condensation and cellular interactions with the extracellular environment (see reviews, [16, 60]). In the embryonic MAN, FN is first deposited in a nonrandom pattern resembling the Meckel's cartilage to be [36] and then on Meckel's cartilage chondroblasts, chondrocytes and perichondrium [36]. In the present study, FN is localized in control MANs on Meckel's cartilage chondrocytes, weakly in the perichondrium, and diffusely throughout the ECM (Figs. 4A, C). MCMV infection induces a substantial change in FN expression so that FN surrounds individual infected and affected neural crest-derived aberrant stromal cells (Fig. 4D). A similar abnormal FN distribution is also seen in mCMV-infected neural crest-derived salivary gland stroma and dental papilla mesenchyme [10, 11]. Since FN plays an important role for mesenchymal cell condensation and cell-matrix interactions, our data suggests that aberrant FN localization interferes with interactions necessary for normal skeletogenesis.

NF-κB belongs to a family of transcription factors composed of NF-κB1 (p50), NF-κB2 (p52), RelA(p65), RelB and c-Rel. They form homo- and hetero-dimers to activate a wide variety of genes involved in many biological functions (see reviews, [61–63]). Since NF-κB1 and NF-κB2 lack a transactivation domain, they can only be activated and translocated into the nucleus when dimerized with RelA, RelB or c-Rel. The IκB family of inhibitory proteins keeps inactive NF-κB/Rel dimers in the cytoplasm. Degradation of IκB allows the NF-κB/Rel complex to translocate to the nucleus, and bind to NF-κB and/or Rel recognition sites to regulate gene transcription. Two NF-κB pathways, the canonical NF-κB1/Rel pathway and noncanonical NF-κB2/RelB pathways, have been identified and their functions investigated (see reviews, [61–63]).

It is well established that CMV infection induces the canonical and noncanonical NF-κB pathways in fibroblasts and other cell types [41–46], which in turn facilitates viral replication [41–44]. We have recently demonstrated that mCMV-induced embryonic salivary gland and tooth pathogenesis is centered around canonical and noncanonical NF-κB activation in NCM cells [10, 11].

Previous studies have demonstrated that NF-κB/Rel plays a role during chondrogenesis and osteogenesis [64–66]. Since nuclear localization is indicative of NF-κB/Rel activation, our observation of nuclear-localized NF-κB2 and RelB in uninfected (control) Meckel's cartilage chondrocytes (Figs. 4E, I) suggests that the noncanonical NF-κB2/RelB pathway participates in normal Meckel's cartilage chondrogenesis. Moreover the de novo appearance of nuclear-localized RelA and RelB (but not NF-κB2) in mCMV-infected stromal cells (Figs. 4H, L, P) suggests that the canonical NF-κB1/RelA (or RelB) is also important to mandibular pathogenesis in a way similar to that seen in salivary glands and teeth, namely the induction of abnormal paracrine signaling [10, 11].

The TGF-β family of growth factors regulates a wide range of biological functions during organogenesis, including cell proliferation, differentiation and ECM formation (see review, [67]). In vivo and in vitro loss-of-function studies have demonstrated that TGF-β signaling plays key roles during mandibular chondrogenesis and osteogenesis [19, 53–55]. In the present study, we found a notable increase in immunodetectable Smad7, an inhibitor of TGF-β signaling, in the smaller, developmentally-delayed mCMV-infected mandibular bone (Figs. 5E, F), suggesting that Smad7-mediated inhibition of TGF-β signaling also contributes to mCMV-induced mandibular pathogenesis.

Loss-of-function mutant mouse studies have clearly established that members of the Hh family play pivotal roles during mandibular morphogenesis and the development of cartilage and bone elements [18, 32, 48–50]. Of particular note here is the observation of mandibular aplasia in E15.5 and older Shh null mice [18, 48]. Although E13.5 Shh null mice present a small mesenchymal condensation in the region of a presumptive Meckel's cartilage in the hypoplastic MANs, by E15.5 Shh mutants exhibit a mere remnant of the MAN with no evidence of Meckel's cartilage differentiation [18]. Presently, we find that mCMV-infected hypoplastic MANs exhibit aberrant Shh protein expression (Figs. 5B, D). Shh, normally seen in Meckel's cartilage chondrocytes, is found in abnormal, cytomegalic stromal cells but not in Meckel's cartilage chondrocytes. There is also a marked decrease in immunodetectable Shh in mandibular bone osteoblasts and periostium. Thus, mCMV-induced MAN dysplasia may also be due, in part, to reduced Shh expression in Meckel's cartilage and mandibular bone, as well as aberrant localization in stromal cells.

MCMV infection of undifferentiated embryonic mouse MANs in vitro induced mandibular hypoplasia (micrognathia) and abnormal skeletal elements. Specifically, mCMV infection of primarily neural crest-derived mesenchymal cells resulted in aberrant stromal cellularity and induced smaller, dysplastic Meckel's cartilages, mandibular bones and condyles due to interrupted chondrogenesis and osteogenesis. Initial localization studies suggest that the pathogenesis is centered around the canonical and noncanonical NF-κB pathways, and there is an unusual juxtaposition of abnormal stromal cells and surrounding matrix. The absence of mCMV infection in abnormal cartilages and a subset of abnormal mesenchymal cells suggests that, as in mCMV-infected glands and molars, paracrine factors likely mediate the viral effect on surrounding uninfected cells. Finally, since it is critically important for normal development that signaling molecules be expressed in appropriate cell populations, the aberrant localization of components of key signaling pathways may reveal the pathogenic mechanism underlying mandibular malformations. That both Shh and Smad7 are NF-κB/Rel response genes provides a good starting point for a wider genomic and proteomic investigation of the pathogenesis.