Anti-apoptotic effects of IGF-I on mortality and dysmorphogenesis in tbx5-deficient zebrafish embryos

Background Tbx5 deficiency in zebrafish causes several abnormal phenotypes of the heart and pectoral fins. It has been reported that exogenous human growth hormone can enhance expression of downstream mediators in the growth hormone and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) pathway and partially restore dysmorphogenesis in tbx5 morphants. This study aimed to further evaluate the effects of IGF-I on cell apoptosis and dysmorphogenesis in zebrafish embryos deficient for tbx5. Results Among the five studied groups of zebrafish embryos (wild-type embryos [WT], tbx5 morphants [MO], mismatched tbx5 morpholino-treated wild-type embryos [MIS], IGF-I-treated wild-type embryos [WTIGF1], and IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants [MOIGF1]), the expression levels of the ifg1, igf1-ra, ifg-rb, erk1, and akt2 genes as well as the ERK and AKT proteins were significantly reduced in the MO group, but were partially restored in the MOIGF1 group. These expression levels remained normal in the WT, MIS, and WTIGF1 groups. Exogenous human IGF-I also reduced the incidence of phenotypic anomalies, decreased the expression levels of apoptotic genes and proteins, suppressed cell apoptosis, and improved survival of the MOIGF1 group. Conclusions These results suggest that IGF-I has an anti-apoptotic protective effect in zebrafish embryos with tbx5 deficiency.

Background tbx5 mutations in humans cause autosomal-dominant Holt-Oram syndrome, which is characterized by congenital cardiac and forearm anomalies. Although the types or locations of mutations cannot predict the severity of the malformation, a consistent heart or limb/pectoral fin phenotype exists in different species with tbx5 deficiency [1][2][3][4][5][6][7]. Deficiency in tbx5 alters multiple transcriptional expression patterns, interferes with mesoderm migration, and causes a wide spectrum of cardiac defects, along with hypogenesis or complete agenesis of the pectoral fins and shortened curved trunks in zebrafish [8,9]. The malformations caused by tbx5 deficiency have previously been described as "premature stops" or "developmental delay" during embryogenesis [10]. The mechanism of abnormal embryogenesis caused by tbx5 deficiency remains unclear. However, previous experiments have suggested that aberrant apoptosis is a key event in TBX5 deficiency-related dysmorphogenesis [11]. Knockdown of the tbx5 gene in zebrafish embryos induces apoptosis and inhibits cell growth, which contribute to cardiac and forearm defects. Furthermore, excessive aberrant apoptosis in hearts and pectoral fins coincides with developmental "stops" on the fail-tolooping heart and fail-to-outgrowing fins [10,11]. tbx5 deficiency also diminishes the expression levels of amhc, vmhc, and cmlc2 as well as disturbs cardiomyogenesis, contributing to string-heart phenotypes in zebrafish embryos [12].
The tbx5 gene is a TBX5 transcriptional factor and a member of the T-box gene family located on chromosome 12q24 in human and chromosome 5 in zebrafish. The similarity of the amino acid sequences of TBX5 between human and zebrafish is greater than 95% [3,6]. TBX5 is expressed on the pectoral fin bud mesenchyme at the 18-somite stage and on ring-like cardiac precursors at the 20-somite stage and involves migration of precursor mesenchymes to form the fins and heart [1,8,9]. TBX5 harbors multiple distinct conserved transcriptional regulatory domains, accounting for its roles in successful formation of the heart and limbs/fins [6].
Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) acts in an exocrine, paracrine and also endocrine manner during embryogenesis in zebrafish and other fishes [13]. Binding of IGF-I to its receptor activates several downstream signaling cascades, including the AKT and MAP kinase pathways, which are highly conserved in fishes and mammals [14,15]. Activation of AKT signaling stimulates a phosphorylation cascade that provokes sequential translation and protein syntheses [14,15]. IGF-I plays an important role during skeletal development by promoting chondrocyte proliferation and maturation as well as inhibiting apoptosis to achieve appropriate skeletal mass and strength [16]. IGF-I is also viewed as a cardiac hormone since the IGF-I pathway promotes the development of cardiomyocytes and improves cardiac function by directly acting on cardiomyocytes [17]. Blockade of IGF-I-related pathways directly influences normal cardiac development and induces cardiac malformation and dysfunction [18][19][20].
We have previously observed that exogenous human growth hormone (GH) treatment can enhance expression of downstream mediators in the GH and IGF-I pathways and partially restore dysmorphogenesis in tbx5 morphants [21]. Therefore, this study aimed to further evaluate the effects of IGF-I on cell apoptosis and dysmorphogenesis in tbx5-deficient zebrafish embryos by microinjecting exogenous recombinant human IGF-I into tbx5-deficient zebrafish embryos at an extremely early embryonic stage.

Animal ethics
Approval of this experiment was given by the Animal Ethics Review Board of National Taiwan Ocean University Aquaculture. Since zebrafish embryos are not considered to be "vertebrate animals" until 7 days (168 h) postfertilization, the zebrafish embryos used in this study were less than 48 h post-fertilization (hpf) and were not subject to the regulation and review process of the Basic Institutional Review Board.

Maintenance of zebrafish
Zebrafishes were maintained in 45-l aquaria heated to 28.5°C with 25 fishes per tank. The water was filtered, and approximately half of the water was replaced at least once per week. Adult zebrafishes were fed once to twice daily with a variety of food, and young zebrafishes were fed twice daily [7]. The tank was cleaned daily by siphoning off any excess food after the second daily feeding. The day-night cycle was controlled with an automatic timer (14 h light, and 10 h dark).

Zebrafish breeding and embryo collection
Zebrafishes reach sexual maturity within 10-12 weeks, but breeding fish should be between 7 and 18 months of age for maximum embryonic production. The day before breeding, 1/3 of the water was replaced and the tank was cleaned after feeding (1-2 h before the end of the light period). A collection box was placed at the bottom of the tank, and preparations were made to collect the embryos the next day. When the light was turned on, we removed the collection box and placed the collected embryos into an incubator maintained at 28.5°C.
Our previous studies used four control groups, including the 3′ end of the tbx5 morpholino (2) (5'-GCCTGTAC GATGTCTACCGTGAGGC-3′), mismatched tbx5 morpholino (5'-GTCTCTTGACTCTCCGCGATCTCGG-3′), wild-type embryos that received a blank microinjection, and wild-type embryos that did not received a microinjection to identify the specific inhibitory effects on tbx5 mRNA translation by the tbx5 morpholino. The effectiveness and specificity of the tbx5 morpholino has been verified by western blot analysis for green fluorescent protein [11,12].

RNA isolation
Total RNA was isolated from 50 embryos using the guanidine isothiocyanate-based TRIzol solution (Life Technologies, UK). RNA samples were resuspended in diethylpyrocarbonate-treated water and quantified spectrophotometrically at 260 nm. The RNA quality was then checked by 1.2% agarose gel electrophoresis after staining with 1 μg/ml ethidium bromide. The RNA stock was stored at −80°C.

Microarray analysis
RNA from WT, MO, and MOIGF1 embryos at 24 hpf, 30 hpf, and 48 hpf were isolated and purified by using a RNeasy® Mini Kit (QIAGEN, Hilden, Germany), and the RNA quality was confirmed using an Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer (Agilent Technologies, Santa Cruz, CA, USA). Purified RNA was reverse-transcribed into cDNA by using SuperScript TM III RT (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA). Before purifying and coupling with a fluorescent dye with indirect cDNA labeling for analysis via a zebrafish-specific microarray kit of 43,663 transcripts (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA), cDNA was hydrolyzed and neutralized using NaOH and HCl. cDNA was then pretreated with GEx hybridization buffer HI-PRM (Agilent Technologies, Santa Cruz, CA, USA) before transferring to hybridization chamber gasket slides for hybridization. The slides were scanned by a GenePix 4000B Axon Instruments scanner (Molecular Devices, Silicon Valley, CA, USA), and data were analyzed by using a Genespring GX 10.0.2, Agilent (Agilent Technologies, Santa Cruz, CA, USA).
Microarray analyses were performed for the WT, MO, and MOIGF1 groups under the same conditions to understand the effects of IGF-I on tbx5 morphants. The expression of a certain gene in the WT group was used as a reference and set to a value of 1. If the expression levels of the same gene in the MO group and MOIGF1 group were both more than 1.5-fold higher than that in the WT group, the gene was marked as "up-regulated". Conversely, if the expression levels of the same gene in the MO group and MOIGF1 group were both more than 1.5-fold lower than that in the WT group, the gene was marked as "down-regulated". These comparisons were analyzed at 24 hpf, 30 hpf, and 48 hpf. All gene transcripts (43663) were screened at these three timepoints. All data were compliant with Minimum Information about a Microarray Experiment, and the raw data were deposited in a Gene Expression Omnibus database (GSE33965) [NCBI tracking system #16217606].

Western blot analysis
Embryos at 48 hpf were homogenized on ice in lysis buffer (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA). Then, cellular debris was pelleted by centrifugation at 12,000 rpm for 20 min, and the supernatant was collected and measured. Proteins were mixed with sample buffer before separating via 10% sodium dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and were then transferred onto nitrocellulose membranes at 100 V for 1 h. Membranes were blocked with blocking buffer (5% bovine serum albumin) at room temperature for 1 h. The AKT and ERK primary antibodies (Aviva Systems Biology LLC, San Diego, CA, USA) were incubated overnight at 4°C using the appropriate dilution (1:1000). The nitrocellulose membranes were washed with phosphate-buffered saline, followed by incubation with a horseradish peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody (1:5000) for 1 h at room temperature before the images were acquired.

Immunohistochemical analysis
Zebrafish embryos were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered saline. Deparaffinized sections (3 μm-thick) of zebrafish embryo tissues were placed on slides and processed for immunohistochemistry. After application of a biotin blocking system (Dako, Glostrup, Denmark) for 30 min, sections were incubated with target-purified rabbit primary antibodies, including MF20, Cx43, MEF, BAD, and BCL2 (all from Anaspec, Fremont, CA, USA); washed in phosphate-buffered saline; and then incubated with a rhodamine-conjugated secondary antibody, goat anti-rabbit immunoglobulin G (IgG). After washing in phosphate-buffered saline, sections were incubated with mounting medium and kept at 4°C.
Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase 2′-deoxyuridine 5′-triphosphate nick end labeling assay (TUNEL) Both whole mount and sectioned TUNEL assays were performed using an ApopTag kit (Chemicon, Heule, Belgium). Briefly, zebrafish embryos were fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered saline. Proteinase K-treated whole embryos or deparaffinized sections (5 μm-thick) of embryos were incubated with the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase enzyme followed by anti-digoxigenin. Finally, embryos or slides were stained with diaminobenzidine for 5 min.

Survival rate assessment
Zebrafish embryos after injection were incubated in 6well plates for observation at 12-to 18-h intervals. The survival rate was evaluated every 12 h until 84 hpf.

Statistical analysis
The results are presented as the means ± standard deviation. Duncan's new multiple range testing was used to compare every pair of test groups. Statistical significance was accepted at p < 0.05.

Microarray analysis of the tbx5 morphants
Using a microarray approach, we compared the RNA expression levels in whole embryos between the WT, MO, and MOIGF-1 groups at 24, 30 and 48 hpf. The results are presented in Table 1. After screening all of the genes, it was noted that most of the IGF-I-related genes were down-regulated during the three stages of organogenesis (24 hpf, 30 hpf, and 48 hpf ). The majority of upregulated genes were ribosomal protein genes. Several apoptosis-related genes and phosphorylation-related genes in the IGF-I pathway were also either upregulated or down-regulated during the process of organogenesis ( Table 1).

Phenotypes of the tbx5 morphants
To confirm the effects of the tbx5 morpholino, we observed the phenotypes and their related gene expression in the MO group. By RT-PCR analysis, the MO group had significantly decreased expression levels of myocardium-related genes (mef2c, ndrg4, cx43) compared to the WT group during the embryonic development stages of 24 hpf (Fig. 1A), 30 hpf (Fig. 1B), and 48 hpf (Fig. 1C). Compared with the WT group, immunohistochemistry analysis also showed that the MO group had decreased expression levels of cardiomyocyte proteins of MF20 (Fig. 1D), Cx43 (Fig. 1E), and MEF2 (Fig. 1F).

Expression of human IGF-I-related genes in tbx5 morphants
As shown in Fig. 2, RT-PCR analysis revealed that the MO group had significantly reduced expression levels of igf1 ( Fig. 2A), igf1ra (Fig. 2B) and igf1rb (Fig. 2C) throughout development at 24 hpf, 30 hpf, and 48 hpf. Expression of igf1 in the MOIGF1 group was partially restored and significantly higher than that in the MO group at 24 hpf. The MIS group and WTIGF1 group had similar expression levels of igf1, igf1ra, and igf1rb as the WT group throughout the examined developmental stages (Fig. 2).

Supplementation of human IGF-I partially improves embryonic defects in the tbx5 morphants
The changes in the cardiac structure of zebrafish embryos were observed via a lateral view. The WT group had an overlapped atrium and ventricle due to cardiac looping formation (Fig. 3A). However, tbx5 deficiency caused cardiac looping defects in zebrafish embryos and induced characteristic "string-like" heart morphologies, which were frequently accompanied by massive pericardial effusion (Fig. 3D). By contrast, the WT group rarely had pericardial effusion (<1%) (Fig. 3A and B). Minimal pericardial effusion was identified in the IGF-I-treated groups (WTIGF1 and MOIGF1) ( Fig. 3C and E). None of the WTIGF1 and MOIGF1 groups had string-like heart phenotypes (Fig. 3P). Thus, the possibility that the string-like heart anomalies were induced by microinjection could be excluded. The MOIGF1 group had a significantly higher percentage of normal cardiac morphology (5% vs. 40% at 48 hpf, n = 100 embryos/stage, in triplicate, P < 0.05) (Fig. 3P). The normal curvature of somites in the WT group was "V-shaped" (Fig. 3F). Seventy-five percent of the MO group had an abnormal curvature of somites, changing from a sharp "V shape" to a round "U shape" (96 hpf, n = 100, in triplicate) (Fig. 3H, Q). Compared with the MO group, the MOIGF1 group had a significantly higher percentage of normal trunk morphology (20% vs. 30% at 96 hpf, n = 100, in triplicate, P < 0.05) (Fig. 3Q). The anterior pectoral fins of the WT group were bilaterally symmetric and developed normally at 96 hpf (Fig. 3K). The MIS group and WTIGF1 group did not have any abnormalities of the pectoral fins (Fig. 3L, N, R). The MO group had a higher percentage of hypogenesis or complete agenesis of the anterior pectoral fins (Fig. 3M, R). Compared with the MO group, the MOIGF1 group had a significantly The expression of genes in the WT group was taken as the reference of 1. If the expression of a gene in the MO group and in the MOIGF1 group were both higher than 1.5 folds of that in the WT group, the gene would be marked as "up-regulation". Conversely, if the expression of a gene in the MO group and in the MOIGF1 group were both lower than 1.5 folds of that in the WT group, the gene would be marked as "down-regulation" higher percentage of normal fin morphology (10% vs. 38% at 96 hpf, n = 100 embryos/stage, in triplicate, P < 0.05) (Fig. 3R).

Supplementation of human IGF-I normalized expression of phosphorylation-related genes in the IGF-I pathway
According to RT-PCR analysis, the MO group had significantly reduced expression levels of erk1 (Fig. 4A) and akt2 (Fig. 4B) compared to the WT group throughout the developmental stages. The expression levels of akt2 and erk1 in the MOIGF1 group were restored and were significantly higher than those in the MO group. Both the MIS group and WTIGF1 group had similar expression levels of akt2 and erk1 as the WT group (Fig. 4A, B). As shown in Fig. 4C, western blot analysis showed that the MO group had significantly reduced ERK1 and AKT2 protein levels at 48 hpf, whereas the MOIGF1 group had partially normalized expression of ERK1 and AKT2. The expression levels of ERK1 and AKT2 in the MIS group and WTIGF1 group were not different from those in the WT group (Fig. 4C).

Supplementation of human IGF-I normalized the expression levels of apoptotic genes
The expression levels of bad and bcl2 in whole embryos were measured by RT-PCR (Fig. 5A, B). The expression levels of bad and bcl2 in the MO group were elevated significantly at 24 hpf and 30 hpf, but expression of bad was within normal limits at 48 hpf (n = 50 embryos/ stage, in triplicate) (Fig. 5A, B). In the control groups, both the MIS group and WTIGF1 group had similar expression levels of bad and bcl2 as the WT group.
Immunohistochemical analysis at 30 hpf of sagittal sections of hearts is shown in Figure 5C1-3 and 5E1-3. Transverse sections of the pectoral fins are shown in Figure 5D1-3 and 5F1-3. The WT group had very low expression of the BAD apoptotic protein (Figure 5C1, 5D1) and BCL2 pro-apoptotic protein ( Figure 5E1, 5F1). The expression levels of the BAD apoptotic protein ( Figure 5C2, 5D2) and BCL2 pro-apoptotic protein ( Figure 5E2, 5F2) were significantly induced in the hearts and pectoral fins in the MO group, whereas the expression levels of BAD ( Figure 5C3, 5D3) and BCL2 ( Figure 5E3, 5F3) were significantly reduced in the MOIGF1 group.
The TUNEL assay revealed no TUNEL-positive cells in the WT (Fig. 6A), MIS (Fig. 6B), and WTIGF1 (Fig. 6C) groups. However, massive numbers of TUNEL-positive cells were visible in the MO group (Fig. 6D). In the MOIGF1 group, the amount of TUNEL-positive cells was reduced (Fig. 6E). Most of the TUNEL-positive cells were clustered at the tail and trunk, although there were several at the yolk sac and head (Fig. 6F). Figure 7 shows the results of survival analysis. The MO group had the lowest survival rate (35% at 96 hpf ), whereas the survival of the MOIGF1 group was significantly improved (65% at 96 hpf ). Both the MIS group and WTIGF group had similar survival rates as the WT group (Fig. 7).

Discussion
tbx5 is a regulator of apoptosis and cell growth, and tbx5 deficiency can induce cell apoptosis and alter cell cycling [22][23][24]. Although the role of IGF-I is not well-characterized in zebrafish embryogenesis, previous studies have found that tbx5 morphants have down-regulated gh and GH-related genes, including igf1 [21]. In this study, we found that exogenous recombinant human IGF-I administration ameliorated dysmorphogenesis, increased akt2 and erk1 expression, normalized bcl2 and bad expression, suppressed cell apoptosis, and improved survival rates in tbx5 morphants. These results suggest an anti-apoptotic protective effect of IGF-I in zebrafish embryos with tbx5 deficiency.  Maternal GH and local IGF-I, which are involved in the regulation of embryonic and fetal development in an autocrine or paracrine manner, are produced in extrapituitary tissues and are present before their formation in the pituitary gland. Though both IGF-I and GH are related to embryonic growth and development, they are thought to play different roles in embryogenesis. This study showed that exogenous IGF-I induced positive effects on embryogenesis in wild-type zebrafish embryos ( Fig. 3C and I), whereas a previous study reported that exogenous GH had little effect [21]. Additionally, it has been reported that the embryogenic effect of GH probably occurs via an IGF-I-independent mechanism [25]. This phenomenon is consistent with the observation that IGF-dependent growth in prenatal life appears to be largely independent of GH [26]. In postnatal mature individuals, particularly at puberty, IGF-I is produced by the liver and extrahepatic tissues and is related to GH [27]. However, IGF-I plays an independent role in growth, differentiation, regeneration, and metabolism during embryogenesis of vertebrates [28]. Though IGF-I has similar effects as GH in mature individuals, IGF-I can be considered to mediate "insulin-like" and mitogenic effects in cells and embryos.
The in vivo effects of recombinant human and fish IGF-I are mostly conserved throughout vertebrate evolution; however, there are functional differences between mammalian and teleostean IGF, particularly in the interactions and affinities with the different IGF-binding proteins in various species [29]. This study found that exogenous human IGF-I provoked the AKT signaling pathway and subsequent phosphorylation cascades in wild-type zebrafish embryos. Delivery of IGF-I into wildtype zebrafish embryos did not increase the mortality and incidence of embryonic anomalies and also did not affect the expression levels of genes related to phosphorylation, apoptosis, cell cycling, and even cardiomyogenesis. Additionally, supplementation of recombinant human IGF-I in tbx5 morphants ameliorated mortality, restored dysmorphogenesis, induced expression of igf1 at the mRNA and protein levels as well as expression of erk1 and akt2, provoked the IGF signaling pathway, and activated the phosphorylation pathway, which is highly conserved across species and plays a central role in organogenesis, including in cellular differentiation, cell proliferation, apoptosis, and somatic growth [30]. It is well-known that IGF binds to insulin receptors, activates the PI3K signaling pathway, and subsequently activates the AKT and ERK pathways. The AKT family of serinethreonine kinases, including akt1, akt2, and akt3, has been demonstrated to be involved in promoting cell survival, glucose metabolism, and cellular protein synthesis [31,32]. Although it remains unclear how human IGF-I functions in zebrafish, our results suggested that the in Fig. 4 Expression levels of phosphorylation-related genes and proteins in the IGF-I pathway in the tbx5 morphants and IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants. The mRNA expression levels of erk1 (a) and akt2 (b) were reduced significantly in the MO group and restored in the MOIGF1 group. Expression of the ERK1 and AKT2 proteins was significantly reduced in the MO group at 48 hpf but was restored in the MOIGF1 group (c). Data are presented as the means ± standard deviations. * P < 0.05 vs. WT; # P < 0.05 MOIGF1 vs. MO. WT: wild-type embryos; MO: tbx5 morphants; MIS: mismatch tbx5 morpholinotreated wild-type embryos; WTIGF1: IGF-I-treated wild-type embryos; MOIGF1: IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants; hpf: hours post-fertilization. The number of specimens was 50, and the number of independent experiments was 3 in each group vivo effects of recombinant human IGF-I were preserved in zebrafish embryos. IGF-I from higher vertebrates still functions in lower vertebrates such as zebrafish. Further investigation is warranted to characterize the complete cDNA sequences and gene structures of zebrafish igfra and igfrb as well as to identify the origins of both transcripts from human and zebrafish, similar to a recent study for maternal GH and embryonic receptors [33].
The functions of tbx5 involve many biological processes, such as embryonic limb morphogenesis, heart development, and lung development. Most biological processes can be influenced by IGF-I. Our microarray analysis found that IGF-I up-regulated or downregulated expression of many RNAs (Table 1). In this study, we only evaluated the effects of IGF-1 on these representative RNAs quantitatively, as well as proteins related to apoptosis (BAD, BCL2 and DAPI) and cardiomyogenesis (MF20, Cx43 and MEF2), and we did not further evaluate the rescue effect of IGF-1 on the other RNAs listed in Table 1. This issue deserves further investigation in future studies. IGF-I can influence most of the tbx5-related biological processes in cardiac looping formation (e.g., pattern specific processes, cardiac muscle cell differentiation, cell-cell signaling, negative regulation of the epithelial to mesenchymal transition, positive regulation of cell proliferation). However, exogenous IGF-I only partially rescued these processes and did not completely restore their function. This study found that the MO group had massive pericardial effusion (Fig. 3C). Although the MOIGF1 group (Fig. 3E) had only minimal pericardial effusion, the phenotype was still more abnormal than that of the WT group (Fig. 3A). Similar results were also observed in the phenotypes of the trunk, length of trunk, curvature of the tail, and shape of somites. The MO group had shorter trunk lengths (Fig. 3H) than the WT group (Fig. 3F), and the MOIGF1 (Fig. 3J) had longer trunk lengths than the MO group. Additionally, both the MOIGF1 (Fig. 3J) and WTIGF1 groups (Fig. 3I) had longer trunk lengths than the WT group (Fig. 3F). Therefore, exogenous IGF-I rescued the effects of tbx5 deficiency regarding the length of the trunk and also stimulated the growth of the embryonic trunk. Although the MOIGF1 group (Fig. 3J) had straighter There were no significant differences in the expression levels of bad and bcl2 between the WT, WTIGF1 and MOIGF1 groups. Zebrafish embryos at 30 hpf were stained by the proapoptotic-related antibody BAD (red) and anti-apoptotic related antibody BCL2 (red) and were counterstained with DAPI (blue) for nuclear observation. Expression levels in the sagittal sections of hearts are shown in C1-3 and E1-3; expression levels in the transverse sections of pectoral fins are shown in D1-3 and F1-3. The WT group had very low expression of the BAD apoptotic protein (Figure 6C1, 6D1) and BCL2 pro-apoptotic protein ( Figure 6E1, 6F1). Expression of the BAD apoptotic protein ( Figure 6C2, 6D2) and BCL2 pro-apoptotic protein ( Figure 6E2, 6F2) was induced significantly in hearts and pectoral fins in the MO group, whereas expression of BAD ( Figure  6C3, 6D3) and BCL2 ( Figure 6E3, 6F3) was significantly reduced in the MOIGF1 group. Data are presented as the means ± standard deviations. * P < 0.05 vs WT. WT: wild-type embryos; MO: tbx5 morphants; MIS: mismatch tbx5 morpholino-treated wild-type embryos; WTIGF1: IGF-I-treated wild-type embryos; MOIGF1: IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants; hpf: hours post-fertilization. The number of specimens was 50, and the number of independent experiments was 3 in each group tails than the MO group (Fig. 3H), the tail was not as straight as that of the WT group (Fig. 3F). Exogenous IGF-I only partially rescued the effect of tbx5 deficiency regarding the curvature of the tail. The normal shape of somites was a "V shape" (Fig. 3F), and the MO group had "U-shaped" somites (Fig. 3H). As both the MOIGF1 (Fig. 3J) and WTIGF1 groups (Fig. 3I) had normal "V-shaped" somites, exogenous IGF-I rescued the effect of tbx5 deficiency regarding the shape of somites. Regarding the biological processes that In the MOIGF1 group, the amount of TUNEL-positive cells was reduced (e). Most of the TUNEL-positive cells were clustered over the tail and trunk, while several were be found over the yolk sac and head (f). Arrow, TUNEL-positive cells. Data are presented as the means ± standard deviations. WT: wild-type embryos; MO: tbx5 morphants; MIS: mismatch tbx5 morpholino-treated wild-type embryos; WTIGF1: IGF-I-treated wild-type embryos; MOIGF1: IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants. The number of specimens was 10, and the number of independent experiments was 3 in each group could not be rescued by IGF-I, we listed these genes in Table 1. Moreover, this study only evaluated the effects of IGF-I on expression of RNA in tbx5 morphants. Whether the function of tbx5 on DNA (e.g., DNA binding) and RNA (e.g., transcriptional activator activity) could be rescued by IGF-I was beyond the scope of this study. As shown in Table 1, the results of microarray analysis revealed that IGF-1 may also act on several biological processes, including the cell cycle, phosphorylation, cardiac myogenesis, and cardiac morphogenesis, in addition to reducing cell death.
One study of the immunoreactivity of IGF-I in fishes reported that the distribution of IGF-I-IR in this species was tissue-specific and age-dependent [34,35]. The IGF-I tissue-specific distribution, in which the igf1 expression level and IGF-I pathway were down-regulated in tbx5 morphants, was coincident with "premature stops" or "developmental delay" at specific sites (i.e., heart, trunk, and pectoral fins) caused by tbx5 deficiency in the proper time window, which are also the counterparts of specific areas with aberrant apoptosis and decreased cell cycling [11].
Several reports have suggested that IGF acts as a survival factor for early-stage human follicles, activating the mitotic cell cycle of both the MAPK and PI3 kinasesignaling pathways and regulating cell cycle progression in progenitor cells by multiple growth factors [36][37][38]. Supplementation of IGF-I to culture media has a facilitating effect on in vitro embryo development, and preimplantation embryos and blastocysts cultured in vitro via decreased apoptosis and increased cell proliferation in mice, rabbits, bovines and humans [22][23][24]39]. Our study revealed a similar survival effect of IGF-I on defective zebrafish embryos. The findings that exogenous IGF-I significantly improved the survival of tbx5 morphants provided further evidence of the effects of exogenous human IGF-I administration.
Currently, anti-sense morpholino administration results in tbx5 deficiency, but cannot completely abrogate TBX5. Therefore, we were unable to determine whether the positive effects of IGF-I on zebrafish embryos with tbx5 deficiency depends on the level of TBX5 decrease or on the residual TBX5 function. Though the TBX5 levels increased in the MOIGF1 group compared to the MO group (data not shown), this result is still insufficient to definitively conclude that IGF-I is capable of rescuing anomalies caused by specific gene defects.

Conclusion
This study found that exogenous recombinant human IGF-I ameliorated dysmorphogenesis, activated the IGF-I pathway, normalized apoptotic gene expression, suppressed cell apoptosis, and improved the survival rate in tbx5 morphants. The results suggested the potential anti-apoptotic effects of human IGF-I in zebrafish embryos with tbx5 deficiency. Fig. 7 Survival of the tbx5 morphants and IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants. The embryos were examined longitudinally under a microscope for up to 96 hpf. The survival rate of the WT group at 96 hpf was approximately 90%. The MIS and WTIGF1 groups had similar survival rates as the WT group. The MO group had the lowest survival rate, and the survival rate of the MOIGF1 group was significantly improved. WT: wild-type embryos; MO: tbx5 morphants; MIS: mismatch tbx5 morpholino-treated wild-type embryos; WTIGF1: IGF-I-treated wild-type embryos; MOIGF1: IGF-I-treated tbx5 morphants; hpf: hours post-fertilization. The number of specimens was 50, and the number of independent experiments was 3 in each group